CORRESPONDENCE - 60A - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

Good evening Mayor and City Council This development would include the historic 1931 Orange County Title Company building. The Orange County Title Company became what is today the iconic Santa Ana based First American Company. It is understood by most that the beautiful "Art Deco" style of the facade remains behind the metal cladding. The Art Deco facade was not removed as it is incorporated into the structure. The art, history & culture are one with the structure. The Art Deco style had an important impact on architecture and design worldwide in the 1920s, 1930s and 1940's. In Mexico City many of the city's highly recognized Art Deco structures were severely damaged during the 2017 earthquake. There is an effort underway to return these buildings to their original glory - much of which had been chipped away by insensitive updates over the decades even before the earthquake struck. Architects and planners are scouring historic photographs and records to rebuild them. It would be a shame to lose one of Historic Downtown Santa Ana's few Art Deco treasures to an Irvine style development, while other major cities proceed to rebuild and preserve that same art, history and culture. It will be said that historic groups have agreed to a plan which "might" preserve only a portion of the building and facades. I say "might" because the agreement includes the term "if feasible," And it is left largely up to the developer's discretion to determine feasibility. The developer, in the reports before you, has disparaged both this fine historic structure AND Santa Ana's First American Company as NOT historically significant. The architectural rendering presented with this partial facade plan is not complimentary to either the art of the original structure — or to the Irvine style development. I don't believe that this developer has any intention of finding preservation of 2 partial facades as "feasible." Bottom line — if this development is approved as it is presented to you tonight — the developer is guaranteed his Irvine style development and the art, history and culture of Historic Downtown Santa Ana (and Orange County) are guaranteed only a shiny nameplate which declares that something wonderful once stood here. Please delay the implementation of the approvals for this development for further investigation and discussions which, I believe, should lead to making the entire historic and beautiful 1930's Art Deco Orange County Title Company building a shining jewel of this development and Historic Downtown Santa Ana. Thank you, Mike Tardif Santa Ana