HomeMy WebLinkAbout12-02-1963MN/IUTES OF ','~ REGULAR ME~TING
OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE
CITY OF SANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA
December 2, 1963
The meeting was called to order at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chambers, 217,
North MainStreet. Roll call was answered by Councilmen Harry H. Harvey,
James Gilmore, Henry H. Schlueterand Vice Mayor Royal E. Hubbard. Nayor~
Ha~l was absent. Following the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag, the ~
Invocation was delivered by the Reverend Jay Weener, Parkview Reformed Church.
APPROVAL OF MINUT~
On motion of Councilman Harvey,
secc~dedbyCouncilmanSchlueter
and carried, the City Co~ucil
approved as mailed the Minutes of
the Regular Meeting of November
18, 1963.
BID AWABD - On motion of Counc~lm-~
Harvey,
MOBILE RADIOS seconded by Counc~lm-n Schlueter
and carried, Council received and
ordered filed a tabulatic~ of bids
received for eight Mobile Radio Units, Spec. 65~-7; approved award of 6 radios
for the Police Department and one radio for the Fire Department (Items 1 and
2) in the amount of $3,924.60 to Radio Corporation of America; approved award
of one portable radio for Fire Department (Ite~ 3) to Motorola
Products in the amount of $731.62; and rejected all other bids.
BID AWARD - On motion of Councilman Gilmore,
FIRE ALARM CABLE seconded by Cotmcilman Schlueter
and carried, Council received and
ordered filed a tabulation of bids
received for 15,000 feet of fire alarm cable, Spec. 634-14; approved award of
the contract to Ansonia Wire & Cable Company at unit prices bid; and rejected
all other bids.
BID AWARD - On motion of Counc~lm, u Harvey,
MAGAZINES seconded by Counc~m-~ Schlueter
and carried, Council received and
ordered filed a tab,,!-tion of bids
receive~ for Library magazine subscriptions, Spec. 335-2; approved award of
the contract to Military Service Co., Inc. in the amount of $2,367.04; and
rejected all other bids.
BID AWARD - Council heard the City Manager's re-
STORM DRAIN port of bids received for the
construction of Storm Drain Project
D-47, with a reeo~endation that
the award be made to the low bidder, deleting Item 6, Catch Basin, with per-
mission of the bidder.
On motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Schlueter and carried,
Council received and ordered filed the report of bids received; approved award
of the contract to James A. Moran Construction Co. in the amount of $22,227.80;
CITY COUNCIL
- 258 -
December 2, 1963
and rejected all other bids.
BID AWARD - Acting upon the Mm=~ger's recommendatiom,
CONCRETE PIPE it was moved by Councilman Harvey, seconded
by Councilmau Schlueter and carried, that
the bid opening date for 13~000 feet of
steel pipe be extended to December 16, 1963.
KEAI~ING - Vice Mayor Eubhard opened the he~
A~. A~. 477 continued ~ Nov~ber ~; ~ ~
SA~A A~ OO~C~L ~n~nt A~lication ~77 file~ ~ S~ta
A~ C~rcial C~, ~c., to rec~ssi~
~ the A 1 to the R h District prope~y no, beast of At~ison, T~e~ ~d
S~ta ~ ~i~oad betwe~ McFa~en ~d ~on. P~ C~ission Resolution
5656 rec~ended denial of applicant's pr~osal.
William We~ke, 201~ Broadway, attorney for the applicant, stated that the
applicatio~ is for pre-zoain~ and that Planning C~=~lssion took no action in
accordance with its policy of not rec~.~m~ending rezoningmass acreage in the
eastern industrial area.
Guy Green, Chief Planner for Moote, Ke~pa &Galloway, Inc., 1905 E. 17th Street,
also represe~tiug applicant, stated that the County has advised the City of
Tustin that it considers area suitable for multi family use.
Cameron Dorsey, 1718 N. Towner, representing the owner of 16 acres to be
developed at the corner of I~von and McFadden, spoke in opposition, citing
traffic problems, the restricted entrance area on Mcfadden, and lack of access
from Lyon Street. There being no further testimony, the hearin~ was closed.
O~ motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded by CounciZma~ Schlueter and carried,
Council denied the reclassification without prejudice.
HEARING - Vice Mayor Eubbard opened the hearing on
A~I). APP. ~0 Amendment Application ~80 filed by
~URROUGNS & SEGERSTROM Burroughs and Segerstroms to reclassify
from the M 1 to the C l, C 2, R ~ and
R 1-6000 Districts property on the ~est side of Bristol between Warner and
Talbert Avenues. Planning Commission Resolution 5560 rec~ended approval
of E~hibit A.A. ~80-B, which would reclassify to the C 2, C 1, and R 1
Districts. The Clerk reported that notice of the hearing was published in The
Register on November 21, 1963 and that no written communications or objections
had been received.
Ted Adsit, 627 Rock. ford Road, Costa Mesa, representin~ the applicants, demon-
strated by a board map the key position of the 160 acres in the f~tu~re growth
pattern of the southwesterm residential center, end noted the restrictions of
the R 4 zone provided adequate control over development. The Planning Director
c~nted that the Planning Commission considered the R 4 a good buffer but
felt it would be to best interest of city to have developer come in with
precise plan. There being no flxrther testimony, the hearing was closed.
On motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Gilmore and carried, the
City Council approved the reclassification and instructed the City Attorney to
prepare an amending ordinance according to Exhibit AA 480-A.
HEARING -
AMEND. APP. ~71
BULLOCK
Vice Mayor Hubbard opened the hearing on
Amendment Application 471 filed by Beulah
Bullock to reclassify from the County M
1 to the City R 4 District property on
CITY COUNCIL - 259 - December 2, 1963
the east and west sides of Ritchey between Newport and Edinger. Planning C~mmls-
sion Resolution 5658 recomm~aded denial without prejudice. The Clerk reported
that notice of the hearing was published in The Register on November 16, 1969,
and that no written c~-..~uications or objections had been received.
Dale Heinly, 611 W. 8th Street, representing property owners Wynn, Borchards,
Snows, Bullocks, Goulds~ and Missler, stated that the request was for pre-zoning
of an area not yet in the city; that it could be developed in the County or in
another city; and that applicants would concur with a staff recommendation for
continuance until submission of the General Plan Progress Report.
On motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Schlueter and carried,
Council continued the hearing to January 20, 1964, 7:30 p.m., in the Council
Chamber, 217 North Main Street.
HEARING - Vice Mayor Hubbard opened the hearing
AMEND. APP. ~1 on Amendment Application ~81 filed
CASE SWAYNE CO. by Case Swayne Company, Inc., to
reclassify property from the R 2 to
the M 1 District on the north side of Palm between Wright and Mabury Streets.
Planning Commission Resolution 5659 recommended approval of Exhibit A.A. 481-A.
The Clerk reported that notice of the hearing was published in The Register on
November 16, 1965, and that no written communications or objections had been
received.
William Wenke, 2014 N. Broadway, attorney for the applicant, stated that the
c~m~any was unable to obtain a loan because of the non-conforming use; that under
present ordinances, if major repair work were needed, c~y is hindered on the
basis of assessed valuation; and it is necessary to protect sizable investment
that employs large number of people and has been in operation long before there
were any homes in the area.
Claude M. Hunter, 1654 E. 4th Street, presented a petition in opposition from
about 73 property owners in the area. On motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded
by Councilman Gilmore and carried, Council received and ordered filed the petition.
Mr. Hunter stated tbmt the applicant's legal description was vague as to the
area to be reclassified and cited as reasons for denying the application, the
possibility of expansion by the company, around-the-clock operation of the busi-
ness, possible sale to any M 1 industry, excessive noise and odors, all of which
would devaluate property values in the neighborhood.
W. G. Statemen, 308 N. ~Jright, spoke in opposition, submitting four pictures
showing traffic congestion and improper purking by trucks in the area. On motion
of Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Gilmore and carried, the pictures
were received and ordered filed. Mrs. Mason, 16~4 E. Palm, also spoke in opposition
noting lack of parking.
Mr. Wenke cited the Cai Compack Company rezoning to M 1 as setting a precedent
for this case. Amos Swayne, 19241 Canyon Drive, Orange, stated that his company
had no plans to expand as there was insufficient land to do so, and that
improvements would be interior only. There being no further testimony, the hear-
ing was closed.
On motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Gilmore and carried, Council
approved the reclassification and instructed the City Attorney to prepare an
amending ordinance according to E~hibit A.A. ~81-A.
HEARING - Vice Mayor Hubbard opened the hearing
APPEAL 105 continued frem November 18, 196B on
V.A. 18~2, GONZ~LW~ Appeal 105 filed by Louis E. Gonzales
from the Planning Commission' s denial
of Variance Application 18~2 to operate a drive-in food service at 2~28 W. McFadden
in the R 2 District.
C~TF COUNCIL - 260 - December 2, 1963
Acting on a letter dated November 29, 1963 from Gilbert and Tarr~ attorneys
for the appellant~ Council continued the hearing on Appeal 105 to December
16, 1963 at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chamber at 217 North Main Street, on
motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Schlueter and carried.
HEARING - Vice Mayor Hubbard opened the hearing on
APPEAL lll Appeal lll filed by the Director of
V.A. 1855~ PERKINS Public Works from the Zoning Administrator's
approval of V.A. 1855 (Arthur L. Perkins)
to waive block wall requirement between commercially zoned and residentially
used property at 1916 W. 17th Street, requesting attachment of a condition to
require dedication on 17th Street to bring the property up to standard of
adjoining properties. The Clerk reported that notice of the hearing was mailed
to adjacent property owners November 26~ 1963, and that no written communications
or objections had been received.
The Director of Public Works, Hugh Foreman, stated the purpose of the appeal was
to obtain dedication of ten feet on 17th Street, to align the property at curb-
line with adjoining properties.
Arthur Perkina~ 2912 W. 17th Street~ applicant for Variance Application 1855,
objected to the dedication requirement. There being no f~rther testl~ny~ the
hearir~wms closed.
0~ m~tion of Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Schlueter and carried,
~uucil upheld the action of the Zoning A~ministrator and instructed the City
Attorney to prepare a resolution de~ying the appeal.
EEAR~NG - Vice Mayor Hubbard opened the hearing on
APPEAL 112 Appeal Application 112 filed by David E.
V.A. 18B4, KELL~ ~eller from the Planning Commission's
denial of V.A. 1834 to construct a 120
u~it, one and two story apar~ut complex on R 1 property at 1901 N. Santiago.
The Clerk reported thatnotice of the hearing was mailedto adjacent property
owaers on November 26, 1963, ~ that letters of protest had been received
from the following:
Elizabeth and Derek Richell, 2410 N. Hathaway Lane, Harold T. and
Juanita R. Craig, 806 E. Catalina Avenue, Mr. and Mrs. C. W. Dozier,
2311 Valencia, Mrs. Jessie F. Emrick, 2~22 N. French~ Mr. and Mrs.
John .c~ith, 2524 N. Fairmont, Ralph B. Lycan, 706 Catalina Avenue,
Mr. and Mrs. Chas. Waffle, 2424 Valencia, Miss Helen Kennedy, 2530
Santiago, Clarence A. Kennedy, 2530 Santiago, ~Theodore Solomon, B14
E. 22nd Street, and Walter L. Harwood, 21lO Santiago Avenue.
On motion of Councilman Schlueter, seconded by Council~n Harvey and carried,
the letters were received and ordered filed.
Robert Rickles, 611 W. 8th Street, representing the appellant, submitted a
brochure of his testimony favoring the application. On motion of Councilman
Harvey, seconded by Councllm~u Schlueter and carried, Council received and
ordered filed the brochure. Mr. Rickles made a presentation of economic infor-
mation from the brochure and added that a comparison of residence sale prices
around Sherry roue apartment development had revealed 'that recent sale prices
had exceeded those of 1962. He noted a survey on Mabury Street revealed that
residents had feared their property would be devaluated by apartments, but
after completion of a garden type complex, property values had risen slightly;
that the proposed type of garden apartments would make an excellent buffer for
the R 1 property. Mr. Rickles quoted from the Planning Commission's report
dated November 11, 1963 and made comparisons with variances already granted.~
He also mentioned that no Findings of Fact had been made at the Planning Commis-
sion hearing.
Ci~ COUNCIL - 261 - December 2, 1~63
Nathan Tarr, 902 Avalon, property owner within 300 feet and attorney represent-
ing protestants, evaluated the emotional and legal aspects of the problem.
Emotional factors involved tradition, precedent, vested property rights and good
faith. He denied that grounds for a variance had been established and quoted
a court decision regarding self-induced hardship. Ne stated Plaguing Commission
did not have brochure Just submitted and cited court case regarding evidence
produced by persons present at hearing; stated increased revenue has nothing to
do with granting of variance.
Eerwin ~acobs, 915 Avalon, stated there was no hardship to property and buffer
required of Guaranty Chevrolet variance was .adequate to protect the R 1 area.
He submitted a petition with over 1,000 signatures of persons requesting denial
Of the appeal. 0~ motion of Counc~ma~ Schlueter, seconded by Couuc~lm-~ Narvey
and carried, Couacil received and ordered filed the petition.
Eugene H. Westmeyer, 6~ E. 20th Street, starch that no hardship existeH but
~wner did not want to sell because of tax purposes. Also speaking in opposition
were Harold Craig, 806 E. Catalima, noting the distance of apartments referred
to by Mr. Rick. les and that approval would set pattern for new apar~mente. William
E. Riggle, 2118 Santiago, requested the reading of Mr. ~arwood's letter, and upon
approval of the Council, the Clerk read the letter in full. Mr. Tarr commented
that Mr. Xeller had leased the property about a year ago with f,,l~ knowledge
that the property was R 1. There being no further testimony, the hearing was
closed.
It was moVed by Counc41m*u G~lmore, seconded by Counc~lm~n Schlueter, that the
matter be continued to the meeting of December 16 for further study by Council.
Cou~cilmau Narvey voted "No" amd Vice Mayor Hubbard declared the motion lost.
A motion by Councilman Narvey to uphold the action of the Pla-~ing Commission
and instruct the City Attorney to prepare a resolution denying Variance Appli-
cation 183~ was lost for lack of second. It was moved by Councilman Harvey,
seconded by Councilman Gilmore and carried, that action be continued to December
16, 1963.
NEARING - AMBULANCE
S~V~CE
in the City of Santa ~na.
Vice Mayor Hubbard opened the hearing on
an application for Certificate of Public
Convenience and Necessity filed by Windh
Ambulance Service to operate one ambulance
The Clerk reported that notice of the hearing was pub-
lished in The Register on November 26, 196B and mailed to applicant and present
Certificate holders on November 22, 1963; that communications supporting the
application had been received from the following:
Dr. L. I. Bonin, 2101 W. Edinger Avenue; Dr. P. W. ~mbert, 1510 N. Grand;
Betty J. Thompson, Administrator, Doctors Hospital, 1901 N. College Avenue;
Allan G. Brown, 430 Milford Road, Orange; and a petition with approxtm-tely
75sign~turesand one'with approximately 25 signatures. The Clerk reported
further that a ~emorandum in opposition had been filed by William F. Acker
and Bright Morgan.
The applicant, ~avid Windh, 555 So. C Street, Tustin, cited the city's ordinance
authorizing an ambulance for every 20,000 inhabitants, noting that Acker operated
one in Santa Aha, one in Garden Grove, and one in Orange, and Morgan operated two
in Santa Aha. Lyle Grimble, 202~ S. Rene, spoke in support of the application,
stating the city could support another ambulance.
William Acker, 2227 S. Bristol, of Acker Ambulance Service, stated in opposition
that the city was well protected and could not support another ambulance, that
cut rates might result, and that there has never been a time when one of the two
services was not available.
CITY COUNCIL - 262 - December 2, l~6B
He also stated he kept only one vehicle in Santa ~na because of the
variance granted him, and he could not Justify having three in this city
at one time.
Vice Mayor Hubbard questioned a Police Sergeant present, who stated that to
his knowledge, on his shift, there had been only about two or three times
in the past year when more than two smbulances were needed in a twenty min-
ute interval.
Bright Morgan, 1322 N. Sycamore, owner of MorganAmbulance Service, supported
the testimony of Mr. Acker, stating he is operating two ambulances in the City,
and requested denial of the application. There being no further testimony,
the hearing was closed.
It was moved by Councilm-~ Gilmore, seconded by CoD]~ctlmau Schlueter, that
the Council find that further service of this type is required in the City
by the public convenience and necessity, that applicant is fit, willing,
and able to perform such public transportation and to conform to the provi-
sions of the Code and rules and safety standards established by the City;
and grant the Certificate.
Counc~m~_~ Narvey stated he believed action should be delayed and further
information sought from the Police Department on such items as gaps in
service, etc,
The motion carried on the following roll call vote:
AYES, COUNCILMEN: Gilmore, Schlueter, ~ubbard
NOES, COUNCILM~: Harvey
ABSENT, C0UNC~: Hall
ORD. NS-696 On motion of Counc~lm-n Harvey,
ANNEXATION seconded by Counc~lm-- Schlueter
and carried, Council continued to
January 6, 1964 action on ORDTNANC~
NS-696 D~CLARING THE~NNEXATION O~T~RRIT0WY DESIGNATED "IRVINE'S SUBDIVI-
SIONANNEXNO. i - REVISED".
ORD. NS-698 ORDINANCE NS-698 AM~IDrNG ARTICLE
A.A. 473 - GRIMM IX OF THE SANTA ANA MUNICIPAL COD~
TO CHANGE DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION
ON A~ENEMENT APPLICATION NO. 473
AND AMENDING SECTIONAL DISTRICT MAP 28-5-10 (EXHIBIT A^ ~73 A) was read by
title.
It was moved by Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Schlueter, that
further reading be waived and Ordinance NS-698 be adopted. On roll call
vote:
AYES, COUNCILMEN:
NOES, C0UNCTLMEN:
~BSENT, COUNCILMEN~
Harvey, Gilmore, Schlueter, Hubbard
None
Hall
CITY COUNCIL - 263 - December 2,1963
ORD. NS-702 0RDINANCM NS-?02 A~ENDING ARTICLE IX
A.A. 479 OF '-'n~ SANTA ~ MUNICIPAL CODE TO
PLANNING CON. CHANGE DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION ON
A~ APPLICATION 479 AND
ING SECTIONAL DISTRICT MAP lO-5-10 (~IBIT A.A. 479 A) was introduced by title.
It was moved by Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Gilmore, and unani-
mously carried, that further reading be waived and Ordinance NE-702 be passed
to second reading.
ORD. NS-?O1 ORDINANCE NS-701 AMENDING ARTICLE IX
A.A. 476 OF '.'~s SANTA ANA MUNICIPAL CODE TO
KLEIII~ CHANGE DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION ON
AM~ APPLICATION 476 AND ~-
ING SECTIONAL DISTRICT NAP 16-5-10 (EYMI~IT A.A. 476 C) was introduced by title.
It was moved by Councilman Harvey, seconded by COU~ctlm~n Gf!more, and ttuani-
mously carried, that further reading be waived and Ordinance NS-701 be passed
to second reading.
ORD. NS-700 ORDINANCE NS-700 AMENDING ARTICLE IX
A.A. 475 OF THE SANTA ANA MUNICIPAL CODE TO
BUVINICH CHANGE DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION ON
A~E~D~IT APPLICATION 475 AND AMEND-
ING SECTIONAL DISTRICT MAP 15-5-10 (E~HIBIT A.A. 475 B) was introduced by title.
It was moved by Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Gilmore, and unani-
mously carried, that further reading be waived and Ordinance NS-700 be passed
to second reading.
ORD. NS-699
A.A. 464
HIDLE
ING SECTIONAL DISTRICT MAP 9-5-10 (EXHIBIT
ORDINANCE NS-699 AMENDING ARTICLE I~X
OF THE SANTA ANA ~NICIPAL CODE TO
CHANGE DISTRICT CLASSIFICATION ON
AMENE~ APPLICATION 464 AND AMEND-
A.A. 464 A) ~ TEE PLANNING C0~-
ISION ~ECO~2~DED D~IAL was introduced by title. It was moved by Councilman
Harvey, seconded by Councilman Gilmore, and unanimously carried, that further
reading be waived and Orally-nee NS-699 be passed to second reading.
oRD. Ns-7o3
INTOXICATION
ORDINANCE N$-703 AMENDING SECTIONS
4250. AND 4251. OF PART 5--INTOXICA-
TION OF ARTICLE l~f OF '.'~. SANTA ANA
MUNICIPAL CO~ AND REPEALING SEC-
TIONS 4250.1, 4250.2 AND 4252 was
introduced by title. It was moved by Counc~lm-n Harvey, seconded by Counci~mau
Gilmore, and unanimously carried, that further reading he waived and 0rdl~ence
NS-70B be passed to second rending.
RES. 63-195
CONDEMNATION
was read by title.
Gilmore, that further reading be waived andResolution 63-195 be adopted.
roll call vote:
RESOLUTION 63-195 AUTHORIZING CON-
D~IATION OF T~F0~ EAS~FOR
WAT~MAINAND SANITARY SE~ER PURPOSES
(Vicinity of Sunflower and Flower)
It was moved by Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman
AYES, COUNCII~EN: Earve~,Gilmore, Schlueter, Hubbard
NOES, COUNC1VN~EN: None
ABSENT, COUNCILM~: Hall
CITY COUNCIL - 264 - December 2, 1963
RES. 63-191 Dale Hetnly, 611 W. 8th Street, attorney
V.A. 1851 - NEES representing the applicant an~ appellant for
Variance Application 1851, requested the
Council to reconsider its decision to deny
the variance because he believed the decision would have been favorable if the
proposed business was other than a liquor store. Councilman ~rvey stated his
motion to deny was not based on the fact that a liquor store was proposed.
RESOLUTION 63-190 UPHOLDING THE DECISION OF ',',~.' PLANNING C0~SSION AND D~ING
VARIANCE ON APPLI~ATI(H~ NO. 1851 FIT.~ BY J(~ F. NEES was read by title. It was
moved by Oounoi!~_-.~ Harvey, seconded by ¢ouno~m~ O~ore, that further rea~i~
be waive~ ami Resolution 63-191 be adopted. On roll call vote:
AYES,
NOES, COUNOILM~:
ABSENT,
Harvey, Gilmore, Schlueter, Hubbar~
None
C~13
RES. 63-190 RESOLUTION 63-190 AFFIi%~INO '~'.~. ~CISION
V.A. 18~0 OF THE PLANNING C0~ISSION TO ~1~ A
HOSPITAL V~RIANCE ON APPLICATION NO. 1850 FI~.~n
BY GOEI~S AND MA~K HOSPITAL~ INC. ~
St~JECT TO CONDTTI(~S was read ~y title. It was moved by ~ounc~m-~ Harvey,
seconded by Counc~m-" G~re, that further ree~_= be waived and Resolution
63-190 be adopted. On roll call vote:
A~ES, ¢OU~¢II/~EN:
NOES, COUNCIlmEN:
ABS~T, COUNOILM~:
Harvey, Gt~-ore, 8ehlueter, Hubhaxxl
None
Hall
~A/J
~ES. 63~189 RESOLU2ION 63-189 UPHOLDING '-'~'. DECISION
V.A. 18~ - AI~ES OF ~ Z~ ~1=~'~ ~ ~G
~ ~OT.~ V~CE ~ V~ ~I~TION NO.
FTT.~ BY ~ ~ ~ JACK D.
G*~-~, ~t ~r re~ be ~iv~ ~ ~esolution 63-189 be a~a.
roll c~l vo~:
AYES,
NOES,
ABS~T,
COUNCIl: Harvey, O~-~re, Sc~lueter, ~ubbax~l
OOt~CiLMEN: None
COU~OILM~.~: Hall
RES. 63-187 RESOLUTION 63-187 APPROVING '£~ ~ClSION
V.A. 1813 OF ,.c~.m Pr_~NlqI]4~, COMMISSION T0 O~ A
CO~ V~OE ON V~ ~I~TION NO. 1813
F~.~ BY W~T~ W. O0~ ~D ~ H.
O0~; ~O ~ P~G OO~ION'8 ~I8ION TO ~OL~E 'l'~ 8~OE STA-
TION P~ION ~ ~ID V~OE ~D ~I~ ~ID V~CE ~ R~T~ 0N
~LI~TION N0. 1~3, ~ ~ ~IONS ~s ~ by ti~e. It ~s ~ve~ by
waived ~d ~solution 63-187 Be a~p~d. ~ ~ c~l vo~:
AXES, COUNCILMEN:
NO~, COUNCIL~:
ABS~T, COUNC~:
Harvey, Gilmore, Schlueter, Hubbard
None
OIT~ COUNCIL - 265 - December 2, 1963
RES. 63-196
QUITCLAIM DEEDS
were submitte& to Council for approval.
Quitclaim deeds to owners of record
for vehicular access rights to First
Street west of Tustin Avenue, and to
Edinger Avenue and Standard Avenue
RESOLUTION 63-196 AUTHORIZI2~G EXECUTION OF TWO D~.~S GRANTING VEHICULAR ACCESS
RIGHTS TO 0WN~ OF REC0~D was read by title. It was moved by Councilman Harvey,
seconded by Councilman Gilmore, that further reading be waived and Resolution
63-196 be adopted. On roll call vote:
AYES, COUNCII24~:
NOES, COUNCILMEN:
ABSEN2, COUNCI~:
Harvey, Gilmore, Schlueter, Hubbar~
None
Hall
RES. 63-192
D~nS-NO CASH
of Edinger Avenue east of Moha~k Drive.
Deed for acceptance was submitted from
Lawrence Siegel, Lawrence I. Bo~in,
Konstantin Sparkuhl, ami Robert F.
Robinson, street easement, north side
RESOLUTION 6~-192ACCEPTING A D~WNERETHE CITY IS PAYING NO CASH CONSIDERATION
was read by title. It was moved by Council~s~n Harvey, seconded by Councilman
Gilmore, that further reading be waived and Resolution 63-192 be adopted. 0~
roll call vote:
AYES, COUNCILM~:
NOES, COUNC ILMEN:
ABSENT, COUNCI~M~:
Harvey, Gilmore, Schlueter, Hubbard
None
Hall
/'~'~" RES. 63'193
Dm~uS & ESCROW
Deeds and Escrow Instructions were
submitted for acceptance frc~ the
following:
Moto Tashiro, real property, Ns/Edinger and Es/Flower, Escrow No. 50~77-K,
$9, ooo.oo.
Ethel M. Coffman, removal of appurtenancy from Lots 15 and 16, Tract 731; and a
quitclaim deed to Santa Aha Valley Irrigation Co., Escrow No. 50665-K in the
smount of $20.00.
Eva P. Osborn, removal of appurtenancy, Lots 1 and ~ of Block 5, Bakers Addition;
and a quitclaim deed to the Santa Aha Valley Irrigation Co., Escrow NO. 50666-K,
in the amount of $950.00.
Edward C. Hagthrop, Jr. and Alice J. Hagthrop, Removal of Appurtenancy of Santa
Ana Valley Irrigation Co. Water Stock, for real property in the City of Sauta
Aha, Escrow No. 50667-K, $700.00.
RESOLUTION 63-193 ACCEPTING D~DSWHERETNECIT~ IS PAYING A CASH CONSID~21ATION
(Osborne, Coffman, Hagthrop, Jr., et ux, Citizens National Bank, Tashiro) was
read by title. It was moved by Councilman Harvey, seconded by Councilman Gilmore,
that further reading be waived and Resolution 63-193 be adopted. On roll call
vote:
AYES, COUNCILMEN:
NOES, COUNCIIREN:
ABSENT, COUNCILMEN:
Harvey, Gilmore, Schlueter, Hubbard
None
Hall
CITY COUNCIL - 266 - December 2, 1963
RES. 63-197 RESOL~TION 63-197 CONCerNING TRAFFIC
TRAFFIC REGUI~TIONS (Prohibiting stopping on
17th Street) was read by title. It
was moved by Counc~lm-- Harvey, sec-
onded by Counc~lm-n Gilmore, that further reading be waived aud Resolution 63-
197 be adopted. 0~ roll ¢,ll vote:
AYES, C0t~NCILM~:
NOES, COUNCILM~2~:
ABSENT, COUNCII~E~:
Harvey, Gilmore, Schlueter, Eubbard
None
Hall
AG~ On motion of Councilman Harvey, sec-
SOIL INVESTIGATION onded by Councf lm~ Schlueter and
carried, Council authorized execu-
tion of an agreement with LeRoy
Crandall and Associates, Consulting Foundation Engineers, for a soils investi-
gation and report at a fee of $2,650.00 for the South Reservoir.
AGRE~2~T - STREET 0~ motion of Counct~m~n Harvey, sec-
IMPROV~ITS, KILROT onded by Counc~lm-u Schlueter and
carried, Council authorized execution
of an agreement with John B. Kilroy
guaranteeing improvements on Harbor Boulevard in accordance ~ith C.U.P. 152,
Condition No. 3 under Utility Release.
CEANGE ~RD~ - PRO~ECT C-96 ~n motion of ~ctlm.~ ~ey, sec-
o~ed by ~cflma, Sc~ue~r ~d
c~ried, C~cil a~ed
~er No. i ~ a contract ~ ~us-
trial Contracti~ ~. for t~ reconst~ction of ~sey Street f~ St. ~ews
to app~xtm~tely ~ feet sou~, ~Ject C-~.
PRIVATE PATROL Om motion of Cou~c~lm~ Harvey, sec-
onded by COl~cflm~n Gilmore and car-
ried, Council approved as recommended
by the City Manager, granting of lic-
ense to Western B~reau of Investigation to operate security service in the City
of Santa Aha.
STREET VACATION On motion of Councilman Harvey, sec-
onded by Cou~cflm~ Schlueter amd
carried, Council postponed to Decem-
ber 16, 1963 action on a proposed
street vacation at the southeast corner of Edi~ger and Fairview Streets requested
by Stater Bros. Markets.
CROSSWALKS & SIGNS On motion of Coun¢~lm~ Gilmore, sec-
MAPLE AND WALNUT onded by Counc~lm~ Schlueter and
carried, Council received and ordered
filed Director of Public Works' report
dated November 15, 1963; approved reccmnnendation to inst~l crosswalk across Chest-
nut Avenue at Maple Street and school crosswalk across Maple Street at Walnut
Street; and denied request for stop signs on Walnut at Maple Street.
CIT~ COUNCIL - 267 - December 2, 1963
PRE. RECORD OF SURVEY 336 Council again considered Preliminary
Record of Survey Map 336 filed by
Standard Pressed Steel, creating two
lots at the northeast corner of Harbor
and Segerstrom, action having been contimued from several prior meetings. Dale
Hetnly, 611 W. 8th Street, attorney for the subdivider, requested waiver of the
drainage fees on the portion of property already developed and waiver of side-
walks on Harbor Boulevard. It was the opimion of the City Attorney that waiver
of the drainage fee was not possible under the wording of the Municipal Code.
It was moved by Counctlm-n Harvey, seconded by Councilman Gtlmore, that the
Council approve Preliminary Record of Survey 336 subject to the conditions
described in the Planning Director's Report dated October 3, 1~63 with the ex-
ception that the side~lks in Condition C thereof sh~l I not be required to be
constructed until such time as sidewalks are required of or constructed on
properties to the north or to the south of subject property on Harbor Boulevard,
but that the subdivider shal 1 file a bond covertng the esttm-ted cost of the
sidewalk construction. The motion passed on the following roll c~11 vote:
AYES, COUNCILM~: Harvey, Gilmore, Hubbard
NOES, COUNCI~EN: 'Schlueter
ABS~: COUNCILMEN: Hall
CROSSING GUARD COSTS On motion of Counc~lmRu Harvey, sec-
onded by Couzlctlman Schlueter and
carried, Council instructed the City
Attorney to prepare a resolution
recommending legislation to force school districts to contribute toward expenses
for school crossing guards.
PRE. REC. OF On motion of Councilman Harvey, sec-
SURVE~ 341 onded by Couactlm-~ Schlueter and
carried, Council approved Preliminary
Record of Shzrvey 341 filed by Fred A.
Mangold creating two C 5 lots at the northeast corner of Wright and 18th Streets,
subject to the conditions outlined in the pIA~ing Director's report dated Novem-
ber 18, 1963.
PP~. REC. OF On motion of Councflm~n Harvey, sec-
SURVE~ 342 onded by Counc~lm-~ Schlueter and
carried, Council approved Preliminary
Record of Survey 342 filed by Herbert
Snow creating two R 1 lots between 5th and 6th Streets approximately 470 feet
west of Rosita Street, subject to the conditions outlined in the planning Direc-
tor's report dated November 18, 1963.
PRE. REC. OF On motion of Counc~lm~- Harvey, sec-
SURVEY 343 onded by Counc~lm~ Schlueter and
carried, Council approved Preliminary
Record of Survey 343 filed by ¥orba
Investment Co. creating two A 1 lots on the west side of Flower Street south of
the Pacific Electric Railway right of way, subject to the conditions outlined in
the Planning Director's report dated November 18, 1963.
Ci~ COUNCIL - 268 -
December 2, 1963
PRE. REC. OF SURVEY 344 On motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded by
Councilman Schlueter and carried, Council
approved Prelimtn-ry Record of ~ey
filed by Rand Development Co. creating
three C 2 lots at the southeast cor~er of Bristol Street and Central Avenue, sub-
Ject to the conditions outlined in the Pl-~ntng Director's report dated November
26, 1963.
PRE. REC. OF SURVET 345 O~ motion of Cou~c~lm~ Harvey, second by
C~ctlm~- Sc~ue~r ~d ca~ied, Co~cil
app~ved ~el~ Record of ~ey B$5
filed by V. L. N. Const~ction ~., creat-
i~ o~ A 1 lot and t~ C 2 lots on t~ west side of ~r~r ~eva~ app~xi-
~ly 660 feet south of McFadden Ave~e, subject ~ the co~itions ou~ined in
~e Pl~nl~ Direc~r's re~ ~d November 26, 1~3.
FINAL NAP - TRACT 4951 Final Map, Tract 4951 was filed by Yorba
Investment Co. to create 187 lots llB1
feet north of Sunflower Avenue and west of
Flower. It was moved by Councilm-~ Harvey,
seconded by Councilman Gilmore and carried~ that Council appr~¢e Tract Map 4951
subject to submission of agreement and bonds, accept the dedications thereon, and
authorize execution of the subdivision agreement°
PLANNED CO~N~Ni~I~ On motion of Councilman Harvey~ seconded by
DEVELOPM~IT Counc~lm~ Schlueter and carried, Council
received and ordered filed a Minute Order
from the Planning Commission suggesting
revision of the PCD Ordinance to allow develol~ment of acreages under the size of
640 acres, to which the ordinance is now limited; and referred the matter to the
staff for study and rec~ndation.
TRAFFIC SIGNAL On motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded by
Councilman Gilmore and carried, Council
received and ordered filed a latter from
Mrs. Gussie L. Thorne requesting a traffic
sig~-~ on 17th Street at the off-ramps from the Santa Aha Freeway and instructed
the City Maneger to notify her of the Division of Highways' Jurisdiction at this
intersection.
W~w~ REMOVAL CHARGES On motion of Counc~m-n Harvey, seconded by
COunCilman Scblueter and carried, Council
authorized the proper authorities to reim-
burse weed removal charges to Glean Well-
Ington, 9B8 W. Camile, $28.72, and James M. Pepper, 2402 N. Oakmont Avenue,
$10.18, after submission of evidence that ,11 196B-196~ taxes have been paid to
County Tax Collector.
TRACTS 4890 & 5115
final maps for Tracts 4890 and 5115.
On motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded by
Coll~c~lm~ Gilmore and carried, Council
denied the request from Argus Homes, Inc.,
for rescission of previous approval of
CITY COUNCIL
- 269 -
December 2, 1963
SOLICITATION REQUEST On motion of COunc~m~n Harvey, seconded by
Counc~lm~n Of]more and carried, Council
granted request of Fairview Therapeutic
Pool Volunteers for an extension of time
to December 31, 196~ of permission to solicit by public appeal, funds for construc-
tion of a Therapeutic Sw4mmiDg Pool for patients at Fairview State Hospital.
SOLICITATION REQUEST On motion of Counct 1man Harvey, seconded by
Council,~n Schlueter and carried, Council
approved the request filed by Blue Star
Mothers of America, Inc., to sell tickets
and program advertising space through February, 1964 for the "Orange County Military
Ball."
PARKqNG REQUEST On motion of Counc!lm-u Harvey, seconded by
Councilm-n Schlueter and carried, Council
received and referred to City Manager for
study and reportt a letter signed by several
businesses in ~he vicinity of Broadway, 10th to Washington, for a survey of par~i~
in the area for possibility of one h~ur park/~ meters an~ for 24 m/nute parki~ on
west side of Broadway between 10th a~ Halesworth.
D0~ BOWL Oa motion of Counci~ Harvey, seconded by
Counc~m-~ Schlueter and carried, Council
received au~ referred to City Manager for
study and report, a request frma the Down-
town Bowl for possible two hour parking in the area.
DOWIITOWN MUSIC On motion of Council,~ Harvey, seconded by
Councilman Schlueter and carried, Council
approved request of Downtown Santa Ann
Association to place six amplified speakers
to each block on each side of 4th Street between Spurgeon and Broad~y and to hang
~ires across city streets, for the purpose of playing music, subject to the approval
of the State Division of Highways.
RES. 63-1k4 R~0LUTION 63-144 OF '£~: Cm COUNCIL OF
BUILDING REGULATIONS T~ CITY OF 8AIiTA ANA REQUESTING THAT Tam
BUILDING STANDARDS C0)~ISSION OF T~E STATE
OF CALIFOI~ ADOPT T~E UNIFOPJ4 BUILDING
CODE, UNIFORM HOUSING CODE, UNIFORM PLUMBING CODE, ~ NATIONAL ~m.~CTRIC CODE AND
U,'~ NATIONALLY RECOGNIZED STANDARDS BY REFACE IN ALL THEIR NEW STATE BUILDING
~iTmI,0~NS was readt~aYttitle. It was moved by Councflm~n Schlueter,. seconded by
Counc Gilmore, ha further reading be waived and Resolution 63 14~ be adopted.
On roll call vote:
AYES, COUNCI/R~:
NOES, COUNCILMEN:
ABS~IT, COUNCIIREN:
Harvey, Otlmore, Schlueter, Hubbard
None
CIT~ COUNCIL
December 2, 1963
WRz',u'E~ CO~dNICATIONS
0n motion of Councilman Schlueter, sec-
onded by Councilman G~lmore and carried,
Council received and ordered filed the
following c~m~unications:
TRAFFIC REP0~T-
Report of traffic control devices removed or inst-ll ed during period
11/11/63 through 11/~6/63.
ORmWG .-
Resolution recommending legislation which would prevent State agencies
from preempting the field of local building regulations.
CON=A.~LT~TION SPEC~CATION CEANGES-
Copy of letter to Public Works Director from Engineeri~ and Grading
Contractor's Association requemting notification of proposed
in construction specificatioms.
E~G~"Z CO~$~dNICATIONS-
Letter from Radio ~mergency Associated Citizens Team (REACT) describing
emergency cc~municatione available through citizens band two-way radio
facilities.
LIQU0ffi~ LICENSE APPLICATI0~S-
Me'N-~is Pizza Parlor, 1180 S. Bristol - NEW ON-SALE
The Galaxy, 900 N. Broadway - ON-SALE G~
VARIANCE AND CONDITIONAL USE P~tMIT DECISIONS-
c~/3 Ma~e by the Planning Commission or Zoning ~mtnistrator, on which no
appeals have been filed.
V.A. 1812, peterson & Rose - to construct an 18 building, 72 unit
two story apartment cmmplex at ~626-4718 W. 5th Street - APPROVED.
V.A. 1819, Eggleton - to replace existing residence with new home
on R 1 lot containing 2 duplexes at 919 N. Euclid - APPROVED.
V. A. 1852, Markum - to construct second dwelling unit on rear of
three R 1 lots at 518 W. Edinger - APPROVED.
V.A. 1853, Gill - to construct third dwelling unit on front of R 2
property at 3311 W. Cam! le - APPROVED.
V.A. 1856, Catholic Church - to construct 16' x 22' room within 9'6"
of rear property line at 707 S. Maxine - APPROVED.
V.A. 1858, Alvarado - to construct three dwelling units on R 1 prop-
erty containing existing dwelling at 5107 W. 7th Street - APPROVED.
~ 7P
ADVISORY C~EE On motion of Councilman Harvey, sec-
onded by Counc~lm-~ Gilmore and car-
ried, the following persons were
appointed to the Citizens Advisory
C~mmtttee for the General Plan Program: Mr. and Mrs. Cameron Dorsey, Alvin
T. Heisser, Sgt Thomas M. ~ey, and Mrs. Leonard Robbins.,
SIG~ E~CROAC~ENT On motion of Councilman Harvey, sec-
onded by Counc~m-~ Schlueter and
carried, Council approved, subject to
approval by the Plenning Director, an
agreement with Animal Medical Center, Eendal P. Svedeen, D.V.M., for encroach-
ing sign at 1414 N. Harbor Boulevard.
CITY COUNCIL - 871- - December 2, 1~63
SOLICITATION REQUEST On motion of Councilman Harvey, seconded
by Councilman Sch-lueter and carried,
Council approved the request of G. T.
Dickinson, pastor of the Seventh-day
Adventist Church to solicit funds from December 7 to December 31, 1963 for medical,
educational and welfare work.
RESZGNATIONS Letters of resignation from the Citizens
ADVISOR~f CO~4ITTEE Advisory Committee for the General Plan
Program were received from Mrs. Loule
Boer and Mrs. Frankye Andres.
It was moved by Councilman Harvey and seconded by Councilm-n Schlueter that the
letters be received and filed, the resignations be accepted, and letters of
mendation for outstanding service and interest in the cc~...~uity be presented to
each.
Acting upon the request of Gordon Bricken, 811 N. Minter, that the Executive Com-
mittee have an opportunity to discuss the matter, Counctlm-u Harvey withdrew his
original motion and moved that Council receive and file the letters and delay
further action until word is received from the Executive Committee. The motion
was seconded by Councilman G~lmore and carried.
AMBULANCE 0~qDINANCES Mr. Acker of Acker Ambulance Co. stated
that Ordinances NS-321 and NS 454 were
in conflict and asked on what basis
Council granted the Certificate to Windh
Ambulance Service. The Mayor asked the City Attorney to review the matter and to
report to Council at its next meeting.
EE~EJiSION OF CD AMENDMENT ORDINANCE NS-707 EXTENDING THE ~mFECT
OF INT~IM ZONING ORDINANCE N8-667
PROVIDING FOR C-5 USES IN TEE CD DIS-
TRICT was introduced by title. It was moved by Councflm-n Harvey~ seconded by
Councilman Schlueter and unanimously carried, that further reading be waived and
Ordinance NS 707 be passed to second reading.
ADJOURNMENT
man Schlueter and carried.
There being no further business to come
before the Council, the meeting was
adjourned at 11:30 p.m. on motion of
Councilman Harvey, seconded by Council-
Correction by
action on December 16, 1963
DORIS M. BROWN
CL~K OF ',T~ COUNCIL
RES. 63-194 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
SPECIAL COUNSEL OF SANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING AND
ASSESSMENT DISTRICT 220 ORDERING THE ~ECUTION OF AN AGREEMENT
EMPLOYING SPECIAL COUNSEL (Assessmen~
~isbrict No. 220) was read by bitle. It was moved by Council-man Harvey, seconded by
Councilman Gilmore, that further reading be waived and Resolution 63-194 be adopted.
On roll call vote:~
AYES, COUNCILMEN:
NOES, COUNCILMEN:
ABSENT, COUNC II/~EN:
Harvey, Gilmore, Schlueter, Hubbard
None
Hall
CITY COUNCIL - 272 - December 2, 1963