HomeMy WebLinkAboutAVITIA, ROSARIO MACIEL (vs. COSA AND IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOM ENFORCEMENT AGENCY "ICE")ADA
americans with disabilities act lawsuit
hearing impared matter deaf
This Release and Settlement Agreement ("Agreement") is entered into by and between
Rosario Maciel Avitia and Greater Los Angeles Agency on Deafness, Inc., (collectively
"Plaintiffs"), on the one hand, and the City of Santa Ana ("Santa Ana' } and the United States
Immigration and Customs Enforcement ("ICE"), (collectively "Defendants") on the other hand.
Each of the parties may be referred to individually as "Party" or are sometimes collectively
referred to as the "Parties."
Recitals
A. WHEREAS, Plaintiffs filed a lawsuit (the "Lawsuit") captioned Rosaria Maciel
Avitia, et al. v. United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement, et al., Case No. 2:16-cv-
04818-R-SK in the United States District Court, Central District of California seeking monetary,
declaratory, and injunctive relief for alleged violations of Title II of the Americans with
Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. § 12131, et seq.), Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29
U.S.C. § 794, et seq.), California's Disabled Persons Act (Cal. Civ. Code § 54.1, et seq.), and
California Government Code section 11135. As set forth by Plaintiffs in the Lawsuit, a dispute
has arisen with respect to effective communication for Rosario Maciel Avitia, who is deaf,
during her detention at the Santa Ana City Jail ("City Jail"), located at 62 Civic Center Plaza,
Santa Ana, California 92703, from approximately May 29, 2015 through November 5, 2015;
B. WHEREAS, Defendants deny the allegations in the Lawsuit;
C. WHEREAS, in December 2016 and January 2017, ICE issued guidance through
Directive 11304 and Amendments to the Performance Based National Detention Standards 2011
(attached hereto as Exhibits A and B, respectively) to ensure that ICE personnel and contracting
facilities are aware of and meet their obligations under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of
1973;
D. WHEREAS, without admitting any wrongdoing with respect to the Lawsuit or
liability for damages arising therefrom and any other purported claim or cause of action, the
Parties now desire to compromise, settle and dispose of fully, all disputes and claims, potential
claims, complaints, demands, and causes of action reflected in the Lawsuit;
NOW THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, including the mutual promises
set forth below, the Parties agree as follows:
Agreement
Settlement Amount. In accordance with and subject to the terms set forth below,
Defendants will pay the amount of $150,000.00 in full and final settlement of all claims
the Plaintiffs may have arising from or related to the Lawsuit ("Settlement Amount").
Santa Ana will pay $140,000.00 of the Settlement Amount and ICE will pay $10,000 of
Page I of I0
the Settlement Amount. The payment of $10,000 by ICE is exclusively in compensation
for plaintiffs' attorneys' fees and costs.
2. Payment of Settlement Amount. Defendants will pay their respective share of the
Settlement Amount to Plaintiffs via either electronic funds transfer or check payable to
the "Almazan & Fineman Client Trust Account" with the Lawsuit name in the reference
line of the settlement check, within sixty (60) days after receiving both the following: (a)
a duly executed copy of this Agreement by all Parties, and (b) a completed IRS W-9 form
from the Law Office of Almazan & Fineman.
ICE's Equitable Relief. ICE agrees to the following equitable relief, to be implemented
within one -hundred and eighty (180) days after the Effective Date of this Agreement:
a. Training. ICE shall train its detention officers in Los Angeles, California as
follows:
i. ICE shall train all Detention Officers within the Los Angeles Area of
Responsibility who have contact with detainees and members of the public
on the requirements of Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973
regarding effective communication with persons who are deaf, hard -of -
hearing or deaf -blind. The training will be sufficiently detailed to enable
personnel to effectively comply with ICE's responsibilities under the
Rehabilitation Act and ICE's implementing regulations, 6 C.F.R. part 15.
ii. ICE will ensure that all newly hired Detention Officers within the Los
Angeles Area of Responsibility who will have contact with detainees and
members of the public will receive the training as a component of pre -
service training and orientation.
iii. The above training shall take place annually for the next three (3) calendar
years, beginning in calendar year 2017, subject to the availability of
appropriations.
4. Santa Ana's Equitable Relief. Santa Ana agrees to the following equitable relief, to be
implemented within one -hundred and twenty (120) days after the Effective Date of this
Agreement:
a. Training. Santa Ana shall train its staff and personnel at the City Jail as follows:
i. Santa Ana shall train all jail staff and related personnel who have contact
with inmates/detainees and members of the public on this Agreement and
on the requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act ("ADA")
regarding effective communication with persons who are deaf, hard -of -
hearing or deaf -blind. The training will be sufficiently detailed to enable
personnel to effectively implement all provisions of this Agreement and
all policies and procedures developed pursuant to this Agreement.
ii. Santa Ana will ensure that all newly hired jail staff and related personnel
who will have contact with inmates/detainees and members of the public
Page 2 of 10
will receive the training as a component of pre -service training and
orientation.
iii. The above training shall take place annually for the next three (3) years,
beginning in 2017.
b. ADA Coordinator for Inmates/Detainees at the City Jail.
i. Designation. Santa Ana shall designate at least one employee with
responsibility to coordinate Santa Ana's efforts to comply with and carry
out its responsibilities under the ADA with respect to inmates/detainees,
whose title is the "ADA Coordinator for Inmates/Detainees." Further,
Santa Ana has designated at least one employee as an ADA Deputy
Coordinator for Inmates/Detainees ("ADA Deputy Coordinator"), who is
available in case the ADA Coordinator is not available. Santa Ana shall
post the name, office address, and telephone number of the employee or
employees designated as ADA Coordinator and ADA Deputy Coordinator
on its website as well as in places open to the public.
ii. Qualifications. Santa Ana shall ensure that the ADA Coordinator and
ADA Deputy Coordinator possess the educational background,
experience, and skills necessary to carry out all of the duties and
responsibilities of the positions, and knowledge and experience dealing
with the legal rights of persons with disabilities and the obligations of
public entities under federal and state disability laws.
iii. Training. To meet Santa Ana's obligation to ensure effective
communication with qualified inmates/detainees with disabilities, the
ADA Coordinator and ADA Deputy Coordinator shall be trained:
1. To promptly identify communication needs of inmates/detainees,
visitors, and other members of the public who are deaf or hard -of -
hearing, and which auxiliary aids and services are necessary in
different circumstances;
2. To secure qualified interpreter services as quickly as possible;
3. To use video remote interpreting services when appropriate;
4. To make and receive telephone calls using auxiliary aids and
services such as videophones, captioned phones, telephone handset
amplifiers, TTYs, and the relay service; and
5. Santa Ana's grievance resolution procedure.
c. Booking/Intake oflninates/Detainees ivith Disabilities. Santa Ana shall
implement or modify policies, rules, directives, and procedures concerning the
screening and classification of inmates/detainees upon entry into the City Jail:
i. To ensure that the ADA Coordinator is contacted immediately when a
person with or claiming a disability is received into the custody of the City
Jail staff. The Santa Ana intake/booking staff shall inform the ADA
Coordinator of the inmate/detainee's name, the nature of the
inmate/detainee's disability, and any request for an auxiliary aid or service
Page 3 of 10
for communication, or reasonable modifications of policies or procedures
made by that inmate/detainees upon intake;
ii. To require Santa Ana City Jail intake staff to document the
inmate/detainee's disability and any request made by the inmate/detainee
for an auxiliary aid or service for communication, or reasonable
modifications of policies, practices or procedures in the inmate/detainee's
record; and
iii. To require the ADA Coordinator or the ADA Deputy Coordinator to meet
with an inmate/detainee with a disability within 24 hours of his/her arrival
at the Santa Ana City Jail and at least bi-weekly thereafter. At these
meetings, the ADA Coordinator or ADA Deputy Coordinator shall ensure
that the needs of the inmate/detainee with a disability are being met.
d. Ongoing Need for Communication Assessments and Consultation. In addition
to the initial communication assessment done at the time the need for auxiliary
aids and services is first identified, City Jail staff will reassess communication
effectiveness, when necessary, during the period of incarceration and will consult
with the individual who is deaf or hard -of -hearing, when necessary, to assess the
measures required to ensure effective communication.
e. Provision ofAuxiliary Aids and Services. Santa Ana will ensure that appropriate
auxiliary aids and services, including qualified interpreters, are made available to
all inmates/detainees or members of the public who are deaf, hard -of -hearing, or
deaf -blind, where such aids and services are necessary to ensure effective
communication, so that such individuals may participate in or benefit from the
City Jail's services, programs, or activities on an equal basis with hearing
inmates/detainees or members of the public. The type of auxiliary aid or service
necessary to ensure effective communication will vary in accordance with the
method of communication used by the individual; the nature, length, and
complexity of the communication involved; and the context in which the
communication is taking place. For example, exchanging written notes or
pointing to items will likely be effective communication for brief and relatively
simple face-to-face conversations. For more complicated and interactive
communications, however, such as an inmate/detainee's discussion of symptoms
with medical personnel or a physician's presentation of diagnosis and treatment
options to inmates/detainees, it may be necessary to provide a qualified sign
language interpreter or other interpreter.
f. Primary Consideration. In determining the type of auxiliary aid or service
necessary to comply with the ADA, Santa Ana agrees to give primary
consideration to the expressed preference for a particular auxiliary aid or service
by an individual who is deaf or hard -of -hearing. "Primary consideration" will
mean that personnel will inquire as to the choice of auxiliary aid or service of the
individual with a disability and will honor the expressed choice unless Santa Ana
can demonstrate that another equally effective means of communication is
available.
Page 4 of 10
g. Use of Interpreting Service Agency(ies). Santa Ana shall form and maintain
working relationships with one or more qualified oral/sign language interpreter
agency(ies) to ensure that interpreting services will be available on a priority
basis, twenty-four hours per day, seven days a week. Santa Ana shall record all
oral/written requests for oral/sign language interpreters and any action taken in
relation to any such request, including the denial of any such request.
h. Use of Other Members of the Public or Inmates/Detainees to Facilitate
Communication. When Santa Ana determines that an inmate/detainee requires a
qualified interpreter in accordance with paragraph 3, subsection (e) of this
Agreement:
L Santa Ana shall not require an individual who is deaf or hard -of -hearing to
bring another member of the public or other inmates/detainees to interpret
for him or her.
ii. Santa Ana will not rely on an adult accompanying an individual who is
deaf or hard -of -hearing to interpret or facilitate communication except:
1. In an emergency involving an imminent threat to the safety or
welfare of an individual or the public where there is no interpreter
available; or
2. Where the individual who is deaf or hard -of -hearing specifically
requests that the accompanying adult interpret or facilitate
communication, the accompanying adult agrees to provide such
assistance, and reliance on that adult for such assistance is
appropriate under the circumstances.
iii. Santa Ana shall not rely on a minor child to interpret or facilitate
communication, except in an emergency involving an imminent threat to
the safety or welfare of an individual or the public where there is no
interpreter available.
i. Phones. Santa Ana shall ensure that the City Jail has two (2) working
videophones and one (1) working TTY to enable people who are deaf, hard -of -
hearing, or who have speech impairments to make telephone calls of the same
frequency and with the same availability as those people who do not use such
phones. If any person who is deaf, hard -of -hearing, or who has a speech
impairment prefers a different method of communication, such as a captioned
telephone or computer, Santa Ana will make reasonable efforts to provide the
communication device requested. Furthermore:
i. Where telephone calls are time-limited, Santa Ana will adopt policies
permitting a longer period of time for individuals using a videophone,
TTY, or relay service due to the slower nature of these communications as
compared to voice communications. If a videophone or TTY is not
available in the same location as telephones used by inmates/detainees
who are not deaf or hard -of -hearing, inmates/detainees who need to use a
Page 5 of 10
videophone or TTY will be allocated reasonable additional time to get to
and from the location of the equipment.
ii. Signage will be displayed at all public telephones areas indicating the
availability of the videophone(s) and TTY(s) and the procedure for using
them.
iii. Santa Ana will ensure that the privacy of telephone calls by inmates/
detainees using a videophone or TTY is equal to that of other
inmates/detainees' telephone calls.
j. Signs. Santa Ana will post conspicuous signs in public areas (including booking
and holding areas) of the City Jail that advise persons who are deaf or hard -of -
hearing of the availability of appropriate auxiliary aids and services, including
qualified interpreters, as follows: "To ensure effective communication with
individuals who are deaf or hard -of -hearing, Santa Ana will provide auxiliary aids
and services, such as qualified sign language, oral, or tactile interpreters;
videophones; and TTYs, free of charge. Please ask for assistance by contacting
Santa Ana's ADA Coordinator or ADA Deputy Coordinator, [name and full
contact information]." The posted signs will include the International Symbol for
Hearing Loss, the International Symbol for TTYs, and a symbol to indicate the
availability of sign language interpreters.
a 0�%
NONME
Boom
some
k. Television Programming. Inmates/detainees at the City Jail who are deaf or
hard -of -hearing will have access to captioned television programming that is
equivalent to the access to television programming available to inmates/detainees
without disabilities in the same classification level.
1. Effective Communication Checklist. Santa Ana shall create an effective
communication checklist for use by City Jail staff. The checklist shall
encompass:
i. Santa Ana's obligations to provide effective communication for deaf,
hard -of -hearing, and deaf -blind inmates/detainees during the
booking/intake of inmates/detainees with disabilities;
ii. the provision of auxiliary aids and services for effective communication;
iii. the ongoing need for communication assessments and consultation;
iv. the requirements to give primary consideration of an inmate/detainee's
preferred auxiliary aids and services; and
v. the prohibition on the use of other inmates/detainees or members of the
public to facilitate communication.
Page 6 of 10
Release. As consideration for delivery of the Settlement Amount in accordance with this
Agreement and the Parties' mutual covenants herein, the Parties agree to waive, release
and forever discharge any and all claims, potential claims, demands, or causes of action
reflected in the Lawsuit, and any other claims, demands, or causes of action relating to
the claims of Plaintiffs which may have arisen prior to the Effective Date of this
Agreement from the same operative facts as those alleged in the Lawsuit, that the Parties
may have against each other, including their officers, directors, employees, agents,
representatives, sureties and insurers, and their successors and assigns, arising from or
relating to the Lawsuit. The release set forth in this paragraph will become effective
when this Agreement is fully executed and Defendants have delivered the checks in
payment of the Settlement Amount in accordance with this Agreement.
5.1 The Parties hereby expressly waive the provisions of California Civil Code
§ 1542, which provide as follows:
A GENERAL RELEASE DOES NOT EXTEND TO CLAIMS WHICH THE
CREDITOR DOES NOT KNOW OR SUSPECT TO EXIST IN HIS OR
HER FAVOR AT THE TIME OF EXECUTING THE RELEASE, WHICH
IF KNOWN BY HIM OR HER MUST HAVE MATERIALLY AFFECTED
HIS OR HER SETTLEMENT WITH THE DEBTOR.
5.2 Each Party is aware that it may hereafter discover claims or facts in addition to or
different from those it now knows or believes to be true with respect to the
matters related herein. Nevertheless, it is the intention of the Parties to fully,
finally and forever settle and release the matters related hereto. In furtherance of
such intention, the releases given hereon shall be and remain in effect as full and
complete mutual releases of all such matters, notwithstanding the discovery or
existence of any additional or different claims or facts relative thereto.
6. Approval. Plaintiffs understand and agree that this Agreement is subject to final approval
by the Santa Ana City Council and the United States Department of Justice. The
execution of this Agreement by Defendants is subject to and conditioned upon the
granting of all such approvals needed to make this Agreement final and binding. The
persons signing this Agreement on behalf of Defendants will recommend that this
Agreement be so approved.
No Admission of Liability. This Agreement represents a settlement of disputed claims
and shall not be construed as an admission of liability by any Party. Each Party denies
liability in connection with any claims and intends merely to avoid litigation.
8. Ownership and Non -Assignment of Claims. The Parties each represent and warrant that
they own the claims that are the subject of this Agreement and have the unconditional
right to release such claims. The Parties represent and warrant that they have not sold,
transferred, assigned or otherwise conveyed any of the rights or claims being released
hereunder.
Page 7 of 10
9. Interpretation. This Agreement has been negotiated at arm's length and shall be
construed as the product of a joint effort by the Parties. Any rule or law that would
require interpretation of any term or ambiguity in this Agreement against the Party that
drafted the applicable provision is waived. The Recitals to this Agreement are material
terms hereof.
10. Integration. This Agreement sets forth the Parties' final and complete understanding
regarding the subject matter hereof and supersedes all prior communications, negotiations
and agreements, whether written or oral. The Parties represent and warrant that they are
not entering into this Agreement in reliance upon any representation, promise or
understanding that is not expressly set forth in this Agreement.
11. Amendments. This Agreement may not be modified except by a writing signed by the
Parties. Oral modifications are prohibited.
12. Successors and Assigns. This Agreement shall be binding on and shall inure to the
benefit of the Parties' successors and permitted assigns.
13. Attorneys' Fees and Costs.
attorneys'Subject to the payment of attorneys' fees to plaintiffs as
required by paragraph 1, each Party shall bear its own attorneys' fees, expenses, and costs
incurred in connection with this Agreement, and the Lawsuit.
14. Cooperation. Each Party agrees to cooperate in the performance of this Agreement and
to promptly take such actions and to prepare and execute such documents as may be
reasonably necessary to carry out the Parties' mutual intent, whether or not such actions
or documents are expressly described in this Agreement.
15. Legal Representation. The Parties are represented by counsel and have had the
opportunity to obtain, and have obtained, the advice and assistance of counsel in
connection with this Agreement.
16. Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in counterparts and/or facsimile or other
electronic means, and, when taken together with other signed counterparts, shall
constitute and be deemed a single original Agreement, which shall be binding upon and
effective as to all Parties;
17. Enforcement of Agreement. It is the intention of the Parties that this Agreement is to be
admissible in court and enforceable by any Party should legal proceedings be required to
enforce the terms of either Agreement. This Agreement shall be deemed to have been
executed and delivered within the State of California, and the rights and obligations of
the Parties shall be construed and enforced in accordance with, and governed by, the laws
of the State of California;
18. Authori . Each person signing this Agreement represents and warrants that they are
fully authorized to do so and to bind the Party for whom they are signing.
Page 8 of 10
A-2017-043
19. Severance. If any provision of this Agreement is held to be illegal or invalid by a court
of competent jurisdiction, such provision shall be deemed to be severed and deleted, and
neither such provision, nor its severance and deletion, shall effect the validity of the
remaining provisions.
20. Effective Date. The "Effective Date" of this Agreement shalt be the date on which the
last Party hereto has executed the Agreement.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have executed this Agreement as of the date set
forth next to their respective signatures.
ROSARIGM8CIEL AVITIA
Signature Date
Rt6�yjo N1�
Print Name
GREATER LOS ANGELES AGENCY ON DEAFNESS, INC.
Signature
Print Name
CITY OF SANTA ANA
r lure
PrinttA me Cynthia Kurtz,
Interim City Manager
Title
Date
A-2017-043
19. Severance. If any provision of this Agreement is held to be illegal or invalid by a court
of competent jurisdiction, such provision shall be deemed to be severed and deleted, and
neither such provision, nor its severance and deletion, shall effect the validity of the
remaining provisions.
20. Effective Date. The "Effective Date" of this Agreement shall be the date on which the
last Party hereto has executed the Agreement.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have executed this Agreement as of the date set
forth next to their respective signatures.
ROSARIO MACIEL AVITIA
Signature
Print Name
Date
GREATER LOS ANGELES AGENCY ON DEAFNESS, INC.
`NA -I pA I
Signature ^�
-Pr,
Print Name t�
V
Title
CITY OF SANTA ANA
Sign9ruve
tt�dca
Print Oune Cynthia Kurtz,
Interim City Manager
Title
O" Page 4 of 10
-MARIA D. HUIeAR`..
CLERK -OF -d k1�U14CIL
Date
Date'G__�
UNITED STATES IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOMS ENFORMENCENT
Signature Date
Prim Name
JL-Ntoq -rglAC OUNSi
Title
Page 10 of 10
EXHIBIT A
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
ROSARIO MACIEL AVITIA, et al.
Plaintiffs,
V.
UNITED STATES IMMIGRATION
AND CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT; et
al.
Defendants.
Case No. 2:16 -CV -4818
ATTACHMENT A TO MEDIATION STATEMENT
OF DEFENDANT IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT
DIRECTIVE 11304, ASSESSMENT AND ACCOMIDATION FOR
DETAINEES WITH DISABILITIES
11304: Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
Issue Date: December 15, 2016
Superseded: N/A
Federal Enterprise Architecture Number: 301-112-002b
1. Purpose/Background. This Directive establishes policy and procedures for U.S.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Enforcement and Removal Operations
(ERO) to oversee and communicate with detention facilities on the identification,
assessment, and accommodation of detainees with disabilities. While Section 504 of the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973, 29 U.S.C. § 794, as amended (Section 504), also applies to
non-custodial interactions, this Directive specifically addresses ICE ERO's interactions
with individuals in immigration detention facilities and family residential centers. ICE
ERO is committed to ensuring that detainees with disabilities receive all necessary
accommodations or modifications to policies, practices, or procedures to allow them an
equal opportunity to access, participate in, or benefit from detention programs, services,
and activities. Further, ICE ERO will take appropriate steps, and/or work with detention
facility staff to assist them in taking such steps, to allow for effective communication
with detainees with disabilities, including through the provision of accommodations and
services as necessary.
This Directive is intended to implement and complement the requirements of Section
504; the implementing U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) regulations,
Enforcement of Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Disability in Department of Homeland
Security Programs or Activities, 6 C.F.R. Part 15, et seq.; DHS Directive 065-01,
Nondiscrimination for Individuals with Disabilities in DHS -Conducted Programs and
Activities (Non -Employment) (Sept. 25, 2013); and DHS Instruction 065-01-001,
Instruction on Nondiscrimination for Individuals with Disabilities in DHS Conducted
Programs and Activities (Non -Employment) (Mar. 13, 2015).
2. Policy. It is ERO policy that detainees with disabilities will be provided an equal
opportunity to access, participate in, or benefit from in -custody programs, services, and
activities, and that detainees with disabilities will be provided with auxiliary aids and
services as necessary to allow for effective communication. Detainees with disabilities
may request and receive appropriate auxiliary aids and services, reasonable
accommodations, and modifications to policies, practices, and procedures (collectively
"accommodations" for the remainder of this Directive) pursuant to ICE ERO and
individual detention facility policy. However, ICE ERO and detention facilities are not
required to provide the requested accommodations if they would create a fundamental
alteration or an undue financial and administrative burden. All approved
accommodations and modifications shall be provided in a manner that is consistent with
ICE's detention standards and relevant provisions of law.
3. Definitions: The following definitions apply for purposes of this Directive and the
associated processes and procedures:
3.1. Accommodations include the following:
1) Any change or adjustment in detention facility operations or any modification to
detention facility policy, practice, or procedure that permits a detainee with a
disability to participate in the facility's programs, services, activities, or requirements,
or to enjoy the benefits and privileges of detention programs equally to those enjoyed
by detainees without disabilities. Examples include, but are not limited to, proper
medication and medical treatment; accessible housing, toilet, and shower facilities;
devices like bed transfer, accessible beds or shower chairs; wheelchairs, walkers or
canes; and assistance with toileting and hygiene.
2) Auxiliary Aids and Services that allow for effective communication by affording
detainees with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills an equal opportunity to
participate in, and enjoy the benefits of, programs and activities. Such aids or
services include interpreters, written materials, note -takers, video remote interpreting
services, or other effective methods of making aurally delivered materials (i.e.
perceived through hearing) available to detainees with hearing impairments; readers,
taped texts, materials or displays in Braille, secondary auditory programs, or other
effective methods of making visually delivered materials available to detainees with
visual impairments; acquisition or modification of equipment or devices; and other
similar services and actions.
3.2. Communication and Mobility Impairments. For purposes of this Directive, detainees
with "communication impairments" include detainees with physical, hearing, visual, and
speech impairments (e.g„ detainees who are deaf or hard of hearing, blind, or nonverbal).
Detainees with "mobility impairments" include detainees with physical impairments who
require a wheelchair, crutches, prosthesis, cane, other mobility device, or other
assistance.
3.3. Denial. A decision to deny a detainee's request for an accommodation, unless the
detainee is provided an equally effective alternative accommodation.
Permissible reasons for a facility to -deny an accommodation to a detainee who has been
determined to have a disability include: (1) the detainee is not denied access to the
facility's programs or activities because of a disability; (2) there is not a nexus between
the disability and the requested accommodation; (3) the requested accommodation would
fundamentally alter the nature of the program, service, or activity; (4) the requested
accommodation would result in an undue financial and administrative burden; or (5) the
detainee poses a direct threat to staff or other detainees.
Both "fundamental alteration" and "undue financial and administrative burden" are
generally high standards that are difficult to meet. Further, if a particular accommodation
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
would result in an undue financial and administrative burden or fundamental alteration,
the facility mast take any other action that would not result in such an undue burden or
fundamental alteration but would nevertheless ensure that, to the maximum extent
possible, detainees with a disability receive the benefits and services of the program or
activity. Similarly, determinations that detainees pose a "direct threat" are generally very
rare, and require a careful, individualized assessment as described below.
3.4. Detainee with a Disability. A detainee with a physical or mental impairment that
substantially limits one or more major life activities (an "actual disability") or who has a
record of a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity
("record of').
3.5. Direct Threat. ICE ERO and its detention facilities may deny an accommodation to a
detainee with a disability who poses a direct threat to staff or other detainees only if
providing the accommodation would unavoidably exacerbate the threat. The
determination that a detainee with a disability poses a direct threat to staff or other
detainees must be reached through an individualized assessment. The assessment should
rely on reasonable judgment and current medical evidence, or the best available objective
evidence, to determine the nature, duration, and severity of the risk, and whether any
modifications of policies, practices, or procedures can mitigate or eliminate the risk.
Detainees with disabilities who are found to pose a direct threat are nevertheless entitled
to auxiliary aids and services or other appropriate steps to allow for effective
communication.
3.6. Fundamental Alterations: A "fundamental alteration" to a facility's programs, services,
or activities is a change that is so significant that it alters the essential nature of the
program, service, or activity offered. Whether a change constitutes a fundamental
alteration is a determination that must be made on a case-by-case basis, and that must
consider the unique characteristics of each facility and each detainee with a disability.
3.7. Interactive Process. The process by which a detention facility engages with a detainee
with a disability who is regtiesting an accommodation to address the disability -related
request, the process for determining whether an accommodation can be provided and
through which the detention facility determines whether the request is granted, and
identification of alternative accommodations.
3.8. Major Life Activities. Basic activities that a detainee without a disability in the general
population can perform with little or no difficulty, including, but not limited to, caring for
oneself, performing manual tasks, seeing, hearing, eating, sleeping, walking, standing,
lifting, bending, speaking, breathing, learning, reading, concentrating, thinking,
communicating, and working. A major life activity can also include the operation of a
major bodily function.
3.9. Physical or Mental Impairments. Physical or mental impairments include: (1) any
physiological disorder or condition, cosmetic disfigurement, or anatomical loss affecting
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
one or more of the following body systems: neurological; musculoskeletal; special sense
organs; respiratory, including speech organs; cardiovascular; reproductive; digestive;
genitourinary; hemic and lymphatic; skin; and endocrine; and (2) any mental or
psychological disorder such as a developmental delay, organic brain syndrome, emotional
or mental illness, and conditions that cause learning impairments.
3.10. Programs, Services, and Activities. The "programs," "services," "benefits," and/or
"activities" of a.detention facility include all aspects of the facility's operations that
involve detainees. These include, but are not limited to, housing placements, medical
care, safety and security protocols, food services, correspondence, visitation, grievance
systems, transfers, and detainee programming and scheduled activities such as law and
leisure libraries, religious services, educational or vocational classes, work programs, and
recreation.
3.11. Section 504. Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. § 794), as
amended. Section 504 prohibits discrimination based on disability in federally assisted
and federally conducted programs or activities in the United States. As used in this
Directive, Section 504 applies only to programs or activities conducted by ICE ERO,
including through its contractors.
3.12. Undue Financial and Administrative Burden. An "undue financial and administrative
burden" is a significant difficulty or expense related to a facility's operations, programs,
or activities. In evaluating whether a particular accommodation would result in an undue
financial and administrative burden, the facility must consider all resources available for
use in the funding and operation of the conducted program or activity as a whole.
4. Responsibilities.
4.1. The Custody Management Division (CMD) has responsibilities under:
1) Section 5.7 (ICE Headquarters Oversight and Reporting); and
2) Section 6 (Training).
4.2. The ERO Disability Access Coordinator (El DAC) has responsibilities under:
1) Section 5.1 (ERO Disability Access Coordinator);
2) Section 5.4 (FOD Review and Oversight);
3) Section 5.5 (ERO HQ Coordinated Review and Response);
4) Section 5.6 (ICE Determinations on the Provision of Accommodations); and
5) Section 6 (Training).
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
5
4.3. The ERO Executive Associate Director (EAD) has responsibilities under;
1) Section 5.1 (ERO Disability Access Coordinator);
2) Section 5.5 (ERO HQ Coordinated Review and Response); and
3) 'Section 5.6 (ICE Determinations on the Provision of Accommodations).
4.4. Field Operations has responsibilities under:
1) Section 5.7 (ICE Headquarters Oversight and Reporting); and
2) Section 6 (Training).
4.5. Field Office Directors (FODs) have responsibilities under:
1) Section 5.2 (Supporting Disability Access Coordinator (SDAC));
2) Section 5.3 (Facility Obligations and Notifications);
3) Section 5.4 (FOD Review and Oversight);
4) Section 5.5 (ERO HQ Coordinated Review and Response);
5) Section 5.6 (ICE Determinations on the Provision of Accommodations); and
6) Section 6 (Training).
4.6. ICE Health Service Corps (II3SC) has responsibilities under:
1) Section 5.4 (FOD Review and Oversight);
2) Section 5.5 (ERO HQ Coordinated Review and Response);
3) Section 5.6 (ICE Determinations on the Provision of Accommodations);
4) Section 5.7 (ICE Headquarters Oversight and Reporting); and
5) Section 6 (Training).
5. Procedures/Requirements.
5.1. ERO Disability Access Coordinator.
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
I) The ERO Executive Associate Director (EAD) shall designate an ERO Disability
Access Coordinator (EDAC) who shall serve as the primary point of contact and
subject matter expert for ERO Headquarters (HQ) and the field regarding the
accommodation of, and communication with, detainees with disabilities in ERO
custody. The EDAC shall have the following duties:
a) Work with other ERO HQ personnel to review information submitted by Field
Office Directors (FODs) regarding denials of accommodations, as well the
identification of detainees with mobility and communication impairments;
b) Work with other ERO HQ personnel to review recommendations by Service
Processing Centers (SPCs) to deny a detainee's request for an accommodation;
c) Work with other ERO HQ personnel to review information submitted by the ICE
Health Service Corps (IHSC) regarding recommendations to deny a request for an
accommodation, as well as delays reported by IHSC in its review of
accommodation requests or in its provision of accommodations that have been
approved;
d) Maintain a list of disability -related resources and equipment available to ERO and
ICE detention facilities, and where appropriate, assist Field Offices in the.
provision of requested accommodations;
e) Evaluate information collected from EID Arrest Guide for Law Enforcement
(EAGLE), ENFORCE Alien Removal Module (EARM), Risk Classification
Assessment (RCA), and other relevant ICE information technology systems
regarding the identification, care, approved accommodations, and custody of
detainees with disabilities;
f) As appropriate, maintain records of detainees with communication and mobility
impairments and records of denials of (and/or recommendations to deny) detainee
requests for accommodations by facilities;
g) Assist FODs, ERO HQ, and IHSC in compliance with the provisions of this
Directive;
h) Develop and deliver training on the provisions of this Directive; and
i) Assist in addressing inquiries related to the care and custody of detainees with
disabilities.
2) On a quarterly basis, the EDAC shall report to the Detention Monitoring Council
(DMC) on trends and areas of concern related to detainees with disabilities.
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
5.2. Supporting Disability Access Coordinators (SDAC). Each FOD shall designate at
least one supervisory -level representative from his or her Field Office to serve as the
SDAC for that area of responsibility (AOR). These individuals shall serve as the main
point of contact at the Field Office level regarding compliance with Section 504 and
associated DHS, ICE, and ERO regulations, detention standards, policies, and procedures
related to detainees with disabilities. The SDACs shall also assist the FOD and other
Field Office supervisory -level personnel in performing the following duties with respect
to their AORs:
I) Ensuring that any relevant notifications regarding disability access and
accommodations, as required in Section 5.3 below, are posted and disseminated in
facilities located within the Field Office's AOR;
2) Ensuring that ERO officers are aware of the need to provide accommodations to
detainees with disabilities while they are in ERO custody;
3) Collaborating and communicating with the EDAC as well as Field Office and
detention facility personnel within the AOR to monitor the care and treatment of
detainees with disabilities; and
4) Coordinating with IHSC to review requests for accommodations requiring IHSC
engagement or assistance.
5.3. Facility Obligations and Notifications.
1) It is the responsibility of the FOD and his or her supervisory -level designees to notify
facilities in his or her AOR of their existing obligations under federal law related to
the accommodation of detainees with disabilities, and in particular that they are
obligated to maintain an interactive process that includes:
a) Identification of detainees with disabilities or potential disabilities through
observation, assessments, screenings, and detainee or third party requests;
b) Notification to detainees of their right to request accommodations;
c) An individualized and interactive assessment of a detainee's disability -related
needs to access the facility and its programs, in which primary consideration is
given to the preferences of the detainee (the facility may consider and provide
equally effective alternatives);
d) Consideration of interim or temporary accommodations where the requested
accommodation cannot be immediately provided or is subject to agency approval
(such as expenditures requiring IHSC authorization);
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
e) A process to inform a detainee of the final decision on his or her request for
accommodations, including whether the facility will provide the detainee with
alternative accommodations that are equally effective as those that the detainee
requested; and
f) The required notifications to the FOD as detailed below.
2) The FOD shall take steps to ensure that he or she is notified in writing by the facility
administrator of the following:
a) Any facility denial of a request for an accommodation beyond the provision of
medication or medical or mental health care. This facility notification must be
provided to the FOD as soon as practicable, but no later than 72 hours after the
facility's decision or recommendation. The notification must include at a
minimum:
i) The nature of the detainee's disability;
ii) The accommodation requested by the detainee;
iii) The reason for denial; and
iv) Any steps the facility has taken to address the detainee's needs.
b) Any detainee identified as having a communication or mobility impairment. This
notification must be provided to the FOD as soon as practicable, but no later than
72'hours after the facility's completed assessment of any such detainee. The
notification must include at a minimum:
i) The nature of the detainee's impairment;
ii) The accommodation requested by the detainee; and
iii) The facility's plan to accommodate the detainee.
c) Excluding IHSC authorization and funding, any need for additional resources to
assist with the facilities' obligations to provide detainees with disability -related
services and accommodations, which may include information, equipment, or
other assistance.
3) As appropriate, and in coordination with ERO HQ and IHSC personnel, the FOD or
his or her designee will provide guidance, expertise, and technical assistance to
facilities in his or her AOR as the facilities develop processes to allow for effective
communication and to consider appropriate accommodations for detainees with
disabilities.
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
5.4. FOD Review and Oversight. Upon receipt of any facility notification related to the
identification or accommodation of a detainee with a communication or mobility
impairment, or to the denial of a requested accommodation, the FOD or his or her
supervisory -level designee will review the information provided by the facility, and take
appropriate action as outlined below.
1) Ensure relevant ERO Field Office staff is aware of the detainee with an impairment or
disability and the need for any accommodations necessary for ERO's interactions
with the detainee, including in verbal and written communications, transfer, release,
and removal.
2) Within 48 hours of the notification from the facility, the FOD will notify ERO HQ
and the EDAC.
3) Within 14 calendar days of the notification from the facility, the FOD will inform the
EDAC of any discretionary action he or she has taken in response to the notification.
Such discretionary action may include, but is not limited to:
a) Consulting with the EDAC for a coordinated response and review of the
information provided, including the sufficiency of accommodations;
b) Consulting with the facility administrator on the need for any additional
accommodations;
c) Consulting with the IHSC Health Services Administrator (HSA) at IHSC staffed
facilities, and with the IHSC Field Medical Coordinator (FMC) at non-IHSC
staffed facilities, as needed;
d) Engaging with the detainee, and observing the efficacy of accommodations that
have been provided;
e) Determining whether a transfer to another facility is a preferable option, following
the procedures and guidelines included in ICE Policy No. 11022.1: Detainee
Transfers (Jan. 4, 2012); and
f) Consistent with requirements of mandatory detention, public safety, and other
immigration enforcement considerations, considering release from custody.
5.5. ERO HQ Coordinated Review and Response. The EDAC and other ERO HQ
personnel designated by the EAD will review all notifications received from FODs or
their supervisory -level designees regarding facility decisions to deny requests for
accommodations, detainees identified as having mobility or communication impairments,
and any requests from. facilities, IHSC, or FODs for additional assistance.
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
10
1) If, upon the initial review of these notifications, the EDAC and other ERO HQ
personnel designated by the EAD identifies significant concerns with a denial or an
accommodation, has questions about the information received, or believes early
coordination with the Field Office may be beneficial, the EDAC may consult
immediately with the FOD or his or her supervisory -level designee, and/or IHSC
personnel.
2) Following the 14 day notification from the FOD, the EDAC and other ERO HQ
personnel designated by the EAD shall review facility determinations and take any
necessary steps, including but not limited to requesting additional information,
engaging with the detainee with a disability in coordination with the FOD or his or
her supervisory -level designee, and working with the FOD, SDAC, or IHSC on any
necessary follow-up.
3) If the EDAC and other ERO HQ personnel designated by the EAD have concerns
regarding a facility's denial of an accommodation, the nature of an accommodation
provided by the facility, or a facility's delay in providing an accommodation, the
EDAC shall discuss the detainee's request with the FOD, IHSC, and Field Operations
personnel at ERO HQ. The FOD, IHSC, and Field Operations shall then, in
coordination with the EDAC and other ERO HQ personnel designated by the EAD,
take any necessary action, which may include:
a) Working with the facility to ensure that an accommodation is provided to the
detainee;
b) Pursuing transfer to another detention facility where the detainee would be
provided an accommodation; or
c) Consistent with requirements of mandatory detention, public safety, and other
immigration enforcement considerations, releasing the detainee from custody.
4) After completing the actions described in this subsection, the MAC, in coordination
with other ERO HQ personnel designated by the EAD, shall report to the EAD all
instances in which requests for accommodations were denied based on a facility's
determination that providing the accommodation would cause an undue financial and
administrative burden or fundamental alteration, including relevant information about
the facility review, and any actions taken by the Field Office and ERO HQ personnel.
5.6. ICE Determinations on the Provision of Accommodations
1) IHSC, Field Office, or contract personnel at SPCs may not issue a final decision to
deny a request for an accommodation for a detainee with a disability on the basis that
a requested accommodation is an undue financial and administrative burden or
fundamental alteration. Recommendations to deny a request on the basis that a
requested accommodation is an undue financial and administrative burden or
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
11
fundamental alteration must be submitted to the EAD to ensure a final decision is
issued pursuant to relevant law and regulation.
2) IHSC Decisions on Covered Medical Services
a) IHSC shall expeditiously review any facility requests for accommodations that are
dependent on authorization as an IHSC covered medical service, to include non-
formulary medications, treatment requiring additional authorizations, and durable
medical equipment.
b) IHSC .HQ will notify the EDAC of any recommendation by IHSC to deny a
request for an accommodation based on undue financial and administrative
burden or fundamental alteration within 5 working days of the date of the
decision. The notification must include at a minimum:
i) The nature of the detainee's disability;
ii) The accommodation requested;
iii) The reason for the recommended denial; and
iv) Any alternative accommodation(s) being provided pending the agency's
final decision on the request.
c) IHSC personnel will notify the EDAC of delays in the consideration of requests
for accommodations or in the provision of approved accommodations. In such
cases, IHSC will coordinate with the EDAC, other ERO HQ personnel designated
by the EAD, and Field Office staff in the review of interim accommodations
provided to detainees.
3) Service Processing Centers (SPCs)
a) For accommodations dependent on external IHSC authorization of covered
medical services, Section 2 above will apply.
b) Supervisory -level Field Office and/or contract personnel responsible for
administering SPCs shall review all requests for accommodations, and all
referrals of detainees with potential disabilities, beyond the provision of
medication or medical care, within.5 working days of receipt or identification.
c) Supervisory -level Field Office and/or contract personnel responsible for
administering SPCs shall comply with the notification requirements outlined in
Section 5.3.2 with respect to detainees with a communication or mobility
impairment.
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
12
d) Any final recommendation by supervisory -level Field Office and/or contract
personnel at an SPC to deny a request for an accommodation beyond the
provision of medication or medical care must be reported to the EDAC within 72
hours of the conclusion of the review. The notification must include at a
minimum:
i) The nature of the detainee's disability;
ii) The accommodation requested;
iii) The reason for the recommended denial; and
iv) Any alternative accommodation(s) being provided pending the agency's
final decision on the request.
3) The EDAC in coordination with other ERO HQ personnel designated by the EAD
shall report all SPC or IHSC recommended denials that are based on undue financial
and administrative burden or fundamental alteration to the EAD. The EAD, in
consultation with the ICE Office of the Principal Legal Adviser (OPLA) and the ICE
Office of Diversity and Civil Rights (ODCR), as appropriate, will ensure that final
decisions are issued consistent with relevant law and regulation.
5.7. ICE Headquarters Oversight and Reporting.
1) Custody Management Division (CMD).
a) CMD shall develop and maintain a data system that will collect disability
accommodation reports and notifications received from the FODs.
b) CMD, with assistance from IHSC, shall compile and maintain a list of relevant
facility resources and capabilities. The list shall contain information about
detention facilities and third party entities known to have medical devices,
equipment, assistive technology, and tools available that would allow ERO to
efficiently accommodate detainees with disabilities.
c) Using available resources and considering any applicable statutory requirements,
CMD, in coordination with IHSC, other ERO components, and FODs, shall on -an
ongoing basis seek to enhance the availability of facility resources and
capabilities described above.
d) On an ongoing basis, CMD, in coordination with the EDAC, shall analyze data
submitted by the field to identify trends, concerns, and areas for improvement,
and shall assist the EDAC in compiling information for the EDAC's quarterly
reports to the DMC.
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
13
2) ERO Field Operations. ERO Field Operations, in coordination with CMD and
IHSC, shall assist FODs in carrying out their duties and responsibilities under this
policy, including by providing guidance on available transfer and/or release options
and other ERO resources.
3) IHSC. IHSC headquarters personnel shall coordinate with ERO Field Operations and
the EDAC in ensuring that FODs receive guidance and assistance in meeting their
responsibilities under this Directive.
a) IHSC HSAs and FMCs shall, as necessary, assist the FOD, Field Office staff, and
detention facility staff with:
i) Providing assistance and information on the assessment and
accommodation of detainees with a disability;
ii) Reviewing specific facility denials of requests for accommodations and
the provision of accommodations as delineated in Section 5.5 above;
iii) Engaging detainees with disabilities regarding their ability to access
facility programs and services; and
iv) Providing detention facility staff with technical assistance and
information on disability accommodations and assessments.
b) FMCS and IHSC HSAs shall review facility disability accommodation practices
and procedures during the course of their normal oversight processes. This
review will address facility policy, procedure, and the provision of
accommodations, alternative accommodations, and denials, including a finding
that a detainee did not have a disability. This review will be supported by IHSC
HQ and relevant findings will be provided to the FOD and EDAC.
6. Training.
1) The EDAC, in coordination with OPLA and relevant ERO HQ offices and personnel,
shall develop training materials to assist FODs, SDACs, IHSC personnel, and others
in the implementation of this Directive.
2) ERO staff designated as SDACs shall participate in annual training on the topic of
disabilities and the provision of accommodations. Should the designated SDAC for a
given AOR change at any time, FODs must notify the EDAC as soon as possible.
Newly -designated SDACs must complete the training on disabilities and
accommodations within 30 days of assuming their duties.
3) Training should include, but not be limited to, the following:
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
14
a) Relevant law, policy, and standards;
b) Identifying a detainee with a disability;
c) Engaging in an individualized and interactive assessment;
d) Allowing for effective communication during the interactive process (which may
include the provision of accommodations, including sign language interpretation,
to, detainees with hearing, speech, manual, and sensory impairments, as well as
language services for those detainees with limited English proficiency);
e) Evaluating requests for accommodations or modifications to policy, practice, or
procedure;
f) Providing appropriate and effective accommodations or services for all types of
disabilities;
g) Utilizing DHS resources to promote Section 504 compliance; and
h) Describing ERO reporting processes for tracking activities related to requests for
accommodations.
Authorities/References.
1) Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, 29 U.S.C. § 794, as amended.
2) Enforcement of Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Disability in Department of
Homeland Security Programs or Activities, 6 C.F.R, Part 15, et seq.
3) DHS Directive 065-01, Nondiscrimination for Individuals with Disabilities in DHS -
Conducted Programs and Activities (Non -Employment) (Sept. 25, 2013).
4) DHS Instruction 065-01-001, Instruction on Nondiscrimination for Individuals with
Disabilities in DHS Conducted Programs and Activities (Non -Employment) (Mar. 13,
2015).
5) ICE Policy 11022.1, "Detainee Transfers" (Jan. 4, 2012).
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
15
8. No Private Right Statement. This document provides only internal ICE policy guidance,
which may be modified, rescinded, or superseded at any time without notice. It is not
intended to, does not, and may not be relied upon to create or diminish any rights, substantive
or procedural, enforceable at law or equity by any party in any criminal, civil, or
administrative matter. Likewise, no limitations are placed by this guidance on the otherwise
lawful enforcement or litigative prerogatives of ICE,
Thomas Homan
Executive Associate Director
Enforcement and Removal Operations
Assessment and Accommodations for Detainees with Disabilities
EXHIBIT B
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
ROSARIO MACIEL AVITIA, et al.
Plaintiffs,
vp
UNITED STATES IMMIGRATION
AND CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT; et
al.
Defendants.
Case No. 2:16 -CV -4818
ATTACHMENT B TO MEDIATION STATEMENT
OF DEFENDANT IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT
AMENDMENTS TO PERFORMANCE BASED DETENTION STANDARD 2011
NEW SECTON 4.8
4.8 Disability
Identification,
Assessment, and
Accommodation
I. Purpose and Scope
This detention standard requires that facilities
housing ICE/ERO detainees act affumatively to
prevent disability discrimination. It outlines the
necessary processes to ensure that detainees with a
disability will have an equal opportunity to
participate in, access, and enjoy the benefits of the
facility's programs, services, and activities. Such
participation will be accomplished in the least
restrictive and most integrated setting possible,
through the provision of reasonable
accommodations, modifications, and/or auxiliary
aids and services, as necessary, and in a facility that is
physically accessible.
This detention standard applies to the following
types of facilities housing ERO detainees:
• Service Processing Centers (SPCs);
• Contract Detention Facilities (CRFs); and
• State or local government facilities used by
ERO through Intergovernmental Service
Agreements (IGSAs) to hold detainees for
more than 72 hours.
Procedures in italics are specifically required For
SPCs, CDFs, and Dedicated lGSA Facilities. Non-
dedicated IGSA facilities must conform to these
procedures or adopt, adapt or establish alternatives,
provided they meet or exceed the intent represented
by these procedures.
Various terms used in this standard may be defined
in standard "7.5 Definitions."
II. Expected Outcomes
The expected outcomes of this detention standard
are as follows (specific requirements are defined in
"V. Expected Practices"). For purposes of this
standard, reasonable accommodations, disability -
related modifications, and auxiliary aids and services
are collectively referred to as "accommodations" or
"reasonable accommodations."
In addition to the'requirements in this detention
standard, the facility shall comply with Section
504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (Section
504), Title II of the Americans with Disabilities
Act of 1990, as amended (ADA), if applicable,
and any other applicable federal, state or local
laws or regulations related to nondiscrimination
and accommodation for individuals with
disabilities.
2. The facility will provide reasonable
accommodations to provide detainees with
disabilities an equal opportunity to access,
participate in, or benefit from the facility's
programs, services, and activities.
3. When considering what reasonable
accommodations to provide, the facility will
engage in an interactive and individualized
process that considers the detainee's needs and
gives primary consideration to the preferences of
the detainee with a disability, as outlined in this
standard.
4. The facility shall develop policies or procedures to
allow for effective communication with detainees
with disabilities — which may include the
provision of auxiliary aids and services — during
the interactive process as well as within the
facility generally.
5. Each facility shall designate at least one staff
member to serve as the facility's Disability
Compliance Manager. This individual will assist
in ensuring compliance with this standard and all
applicable federal, state and local laws related to
4.8 1 Disability Identification, Assessment, and 344 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
accommodations for detainees with disabilities.
6. The facility orientation program and the detainee
handbook shall notify and inform detainees about
the facility's disability accommodations policy,
including their right to request reasonable
accommodations and how to make such a
request.
7. Facility staff shall receive training on reasonable
accommodations policies and procedures, to
include the actions they must take upon
identifying a detainee with a disability who may
require an accommodation, modification, and/or
auxiliary aid or service.
8. The facility shall provide detainees with
disabilities who are limited in their English
proficiency (LEP) with meaningful access to its
programs and activities through language
assistance, including bilingual staff or
professional interpretation and translation
services. Meaningful access to facility programs
and activities includes the effective
communication of the applicable content and
procedures in this standard.
9. The facility shall provide physical access to
programs and activities in the least restrictive
setting possible, and in the most integrated
setting appropriate to the needs of the detainee
with a disability. Detainees with disabilities
requiring an assistive device, such as a crutch or
wheelchair, shall normally be permitted to keep
those items with them at all times. Removal of
any such devices because of concerns related to
safety and security must be based on
individualized review and the justification
documented. A detainee's disability or need for
assistive devices or equipment may not provide
the sole basis for the facility's decision to place
the detainee apart from the general population.
10. Compliance with the reasonable
accommodations policies and procedures
articulated in this standard shall be consistently
documented where practicable, as stated in this
standard.
11. The facility administrator shall convene a
multidisciplinary team to assess the cases of
detainees with communication and mobility
impairments, detainees whose initial requests for
accommodations have been denied, and complex
cases. The multidisciplinary team will determine
whether the detainee has a disability, whether
the detainee requires an accommodation to
access the facility's programs and activities, and
whether to grant or recommend denying the
requested accommodation. Any denial by the
multidisciplinary team of a request for
accommodation related to a disability must be
approved by the facility administrator or assistant
facility administrator.
12. The local ICE/ERO Field Office shall be notified
no later than 72 hours after the completed
review and assessment of any detainee with a
communication or mobility impairment.
Facilities shall also notify the Field Office within
72 hours of any denial of a detainee's request for
a disability -related accommodation.
13. Detainees shall be permitted to raise concerns
about disability -related accommodations and/or
the accommodations process through the
grievance system, as outlined in standard 6.2
"Grievance System." Facilities shall ensure that
detainees with disabilities have equal
opportunity to access and participate in the
grievance system, including by allowing for
effective communication, which can include the
provision of auxiliary aids and services,
throughout the process.
III. Standards Affected
Not applicable.
IV. References
ICE/ERO Performance -Based Nadonal Detention
4.8 j Disability Identification, Assessment, and 345 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
Standards 1071:
• "1.3 Transportation (by Land)";
• "2.1 Admission and Release";
• "2,2 Custody Classification System";
• "2.6 Hold Rooms in Detention Facilities";
• "2.11 Sexual Abuse and Assault Prevention and
Intervention";
• "2.13 Staff -Detainee Communication";
• "3.1 Disciplinary System";
• "4.3 Medical Care";
"4.5 Personal Hygiene";
• "5.2 Trips for Non -Medical Emergencies";
• 5.4 Recreation";
• 5.5 Religious Practices';
• 5.6 Telephone Access";
• 5.8 Voluntary Work Program";
• "6.2 Grievance System"; and
• "7.3 Staff Training."
Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of
1990, as amended, and its implementing regulation
at 28 C.F.R. Part 35.
The Architectural Barriers Act of 1968, as amended.
Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and
DHS implementing regulation at 6 C.F.R. Part 15.
DHS Directive 065-01, "Nondiscrimination for
Individuals with Disabilities in DHS -conducted
Programs and Activities (Non -Employment)" (Sept,
25, 2013).
ICE Directive "Assessment and Accommodations for
Detainees with Disabilities" (December 15, 2016).
ICE Policy No. 11065.1, "Review of the Use of
Segregation for ICE Detainees" (Sept. 4, 2013).
V. Expected Practices
A. Definitions
1. Disability
For purposes of these detention standards, the term
"disability" means either of the below:
a. a physical or mental impairment that substantially
limits one or more of an individual's major life
activities; or
b. a record of such a physical or mental impairment
"Major life activities" are basic activities that a
detainee without a disability in the general
population can perform with little or no difficulty,
including, but not limited to, caring for oneself,
performing manual tasks, seeing, hearing, eating,
sleeping, walking, standing, lifting, bending,
speaking, breathing, learning, reading,
concentrating, thinking, communicating, and
working. A major life activity can also include the
operation of major bodily functions, like the
immune, endocrine, and neurological systems;
normal cell growth; digestion, respiration, and
circulation; and the operations of the bowel,
bladder, and brain.
2. Communication Impairments
Detainees with "communication impairments'
include detainees with physical, hearing, vision, and
speech impairments (e.g., detainees who have
hearing loss or are deaf; blind; have visual
impairments; or nonverbal).
3. Mobility Impairments
Detainees with "mobility impairments" include
detainees with physical impairments who require a
wheelchair, crutches, prosthesis, cane, or other
mobility device, or other assistance.
4. Programs, Services, or Activities
For purposes of these standards, the "programs,"
"services," "benefits," and/or "activities" of a
4.8 j Disability Identification, Assessment, and 346 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
detention facility include all aspects of the facility's
operations that involve detainees. These include, but
are not limited to, housing placements, medical care,
safety and security protocols, food services,
correspondence, visitation, grievance systems,
transfers, and detainee programming and scheduled
activities such as law and leisure libraries, religious
services, educational or vocational classes, work
programs, and recreation.
& Auxiliary Aids or Services
"Auxiliary aids or services" are services or devices
that allow for effective communication by affording
individuals with impaired vision, hearing, speaking,
sensory, and manual skills an equal opportunity to
participate in, and enjoy the benefits of, programs
and activities. Such aids or services include
interpreters, written materials, note -takers, video
remote interpreting services, or other effective
methods of making aurally delivered materials
available to detainees with hearing impairments;
readers, taped texts, materials or displays in Braille,
secondary auditory programs, or other effective
methods of making visually delivered materials
available to detainees with visual impairments;
acquisition or modification of equipment or devices;
and other similar services and actions.
6. Reasonable Accommodations
For purposes of these standards, "reasonable
accommodation" means any change or adjustment
in detention facility operations, any modification to
detention facility policy, practice, or procedure, or
any provision of an aid or service that permits a
detainee with a disability to participate in the
facility's programs, services, activities, or
requirements, or to enjoy the benefits and privileges
of detention programs equal to those enjoyed by
detainees without disabilities. Examples of
"reasonable accommodations" include, but are not
limited to, proper medication and medical
treatment; accessible housing, toilet, and shower
facilities; devices like bed transfer, accessible beds or
shower chairs, hearing aids, or canes; and assistance
with toileting and hygiene.
When considering requests for reasonable
accommodations or modifications, the facility shall
engage in an interactive and individualized process
as outlined in section F below.
For the purposes of this standard, and particularly
section F below, reasonable accommodations,
disability -related modifications, and auxiliary aids
and services are collectively referred to as
"accommodations" or "reasonable
accommodations."
B. Written Policy and Procedures, and
Compliance Manager
1. Reasonable Accommodation Policy
The facility shall develop written policy and
procedures, including reasonable timelines, for
reviewing detainees' requests for accommodations
related to a disability and for providing
accommodations (including interim
accommodations), modifications, and reassessments.
These policies and procedures shall be consistent
with the processes outlined in this standard.
2. Disability Compliance Manager
The facility shall designate a Disability Compliance
Manager to assist facility personnel in ensuring
compliance with this standard and all applicable
federal, state, and local laws related to
accommodation of detainees with disabilities. The
Disability Compliance Manager may be the Health
Services Administrator, a member of the medical
staff, or anyone with relevant knowledge, education,
and/or experience.
C. Identification
A detainee may identify him- or herself as having a
disability and/or request a reasonable
accommodation at any point during detention.
Detainees may submit a formal or informal (i.e.,
verbal or written) request for accommodations or
4.8 1 Disability Identification, Assessment, and 347 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
assistance. Requests should be reviewed in context,
and do not need to include the words "disability" or
"accommodation" to be considered a request for
accommodations. The facility shall also consider
information submitted by a third party, such as an
attorney, family member, or other detainee
identifying a detainee with a disability or a
detainee's need for an accommodation.
Further, it is incumbent upon facility staff to identify
detainees with impairments that are open, obvious,
and apparent. Identification of detainees with
potential disabilities (i.e., impairments that are open,
obvious, and apparent) may occur through medical
Pr intake screenings, or through direct observation.
Staff should be particularly vigilant for impairments
that affect a detainee's mobility or ability to
communicate. Upon identifying a detainee with a
potential disability, the facility shall review the need
for any necessary accommodations pursuant to
Section F below.
The processes described in this standard apply to any
detainee who has requested an accommodation or
auxiliary aid or service, or who has otherwise been
identified as potentially needing an accommodation.
D. Physical Accessibility and Most
Integrated Setting Possible
1. Physical Accessibility
The facility shall comply with all applicable federal,
state, and local laws and regulations related to the
accessibility of safe and appropriate housing for
detainees with disabilities.
The facility will ensure that detainees with
disabilities are able to physically access its programs,
services, and activities. This includes, for example,
ensuring detainees with disabilities can access
telephones, as well as toileting and bathing facilities,
2. Most Integrated Setting
Every detainee with a disability will be housed in a
space that affords him or her safe, appropriate living
conditions. Detainees with disabilities should be
provided access to the facility's programs and
services in the least restrictive setting possible and
the most integrated setting appropriate to the needs
of the detainee with a disability.
Detainees with disabilities shall generally be
permitted to keep assistive devices (including such
aids as canes and crutches) with them at all times,
including in general population. Placement apart
from the general population due to security concerns
related to the use of any such item must be based on
individualized review, and the justification for the
placement must be documented, whether the
detainee is placed in an SMU, medical clinic, or
elsewhere. The justification shall set forth the
individualized assessment of the safety or security
concern created by the assistive device that could not
be eliminated or mitigated by modification of
policies or proceduzes.
A detainee's disability or need for accommodations
may not provide the sole basis for a decision to place
the detainee in an SMU. An individualized
assessment must be made in each case, and the
justification for the placement documented.
E. Effective Communication
Throughout the facility's programs and activities, '
including at all stages of the reasonable
accommodation process, the facility must take
appropriate steps to allow for effective
communication with detainees with disabilities to'
afford them an equal opportunity to participate in,
and enjoy the benefits of the facility's programs and
activities. Steps to ensure effective communication
may include the provision and use of auxiliary aids
or services for detainees with vision, hearing,
sensory, speech, and manual impairments, as
needed. The type of auxiliary aid or service
necessary to ensure effective communication will
vary in accordance with the method of
communication used by the individual detainee, the
nature, length, and complexity of the
4.8 1 Disability Identification, Assessment, and 348 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
communication involved, and the context in which
the communication is taking place. In determining
what types of auxiliary aids or services are necessary,
the facility shall give primary consideration to the
request of the detainee with a disability.
Use of other detainees to interpret or facilitate
communication with a detainee with a disability
may only occur in emergencies.
F. Reasonable Accommodations Process
The facility's process to appropriately accommodate
a detainee with a disability will differ depending on
the nature of the impairment or disability being
addressed. However, in certain cases, the facility
administrator or his or her designee shall
automatically convene a multidisciplinary team, as
described in section 4 below.
1. Immediate Accommodations
The facility shall provide detainees with disabilities
with necessary accommodations in an expeditious
manner. In many situations, the facility will be able
to immediately grant a detainee's request for an
accommodation. Where a request for
accommodation is immediately granted and
provided, and the accommodation fully addresses
the detainee's ability to access the facility's programs
and activities, the facility's response will not .
ordinarily involve referral to a multidisciplinary
team.
2. Medical and Mental Health Treatment
Many detainees with disabilities will receive medical
and/or mental health treatment from the facility's
clinical medical authority. Where a detainee with a
disability is fully able to access the facility's
programs and activities through the provision of
appropriate medical or mental health treatment,
further interactive process may not be necessary.
However, where the provision of accommodations
depends on medical expenditures requiring ICE
authorization, the facility shall consider whether
there are any interim accommodations that would
afford the detainee access to its programs and
activities pending ICE authorization (for example,
providing a wheelchair as an interim
accommodation to allow for mobility while a
prosthesis is repaired), and shall provide to the
detainee any such interim accommodations it
identifies.
3. Detainees with Cognitive, Intellectual, or
Developmental Disabilities
Referral to the multidisciplinary team may be
appropriate for detainees who are identified as
having a cognitive, intellectual, or developmental
disability, including a traumatic brain injury. Such
detainees may face difficulties navigating the
detention environment, including disciplinary,
grievance, and other processes. Additionally, such
detainees may not understand the process for
requesting an accommodation or be aware of
limitations on their access to facility
programs. Facility staff should not require the
detainee's participation in the assessment process,
and should be sensitive to the fact that some
detainees in this category may not perceive
themselves as having a disability. However, facility
staff should provide appropriate assistance to a
detainee with a cognitive, intellectual, or
developmental disability, even if not explicitly
requested (for example, reading and explaining a
form to a detainee with limited cognitive abilities).
Pursuant to Standard 4.3 "Medical Care,'" the facility
is also required to report the identification of
detainees with certain cognitive, intellectual, or
developmental disabilities to the ICE/ERO Field
Office.
4. Multidisciplinary Team
Requests or referrals that require an evaluation by a
multidisciplinary team include (1) detainees with
mobility impairments; (2) detainees with
communication impairments; (3) detainees whose
initial requests for accommodations or assistance
have been denied; (4) detainees who have fled
4.8 1 Disability Identification, Assessment, and 349 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
grievances about the accommodation of their
disabilities or impairments; (5) detainees whose
requests are complex or best addressed by staff from
more than one discipline (e.g., security,
programming, medical, or mental health, etc.); and
(6) detainees whose cases are otherwise determined
by facility staff to be appropriate for referral to the
team.
The multidisciplinary team will include a healthcare
professional and any additional facility staff with
requisite knowledge of and/or responsibility for
compliance with disability policies and procedures.
The team may consist of two or more staff and may
have different members at different times,
depending on the detainee or request for
accommodations under review. When appropriate,
the multidisciplinary team shall consult with
ICE/ERO to obtain guidance, information, and/or
resources for providing accommodations.
The team is encouraged to consult with local and
community resources that may have subject matter
expertise on the provision of accommodations,
modifications, and services.. This consultation may
include training, information on the availability of
accommodations and services, and best practices.
However, all external communications regarding
individual detainees are subject to applicable privacy
limitations and protections and must be conducted
in a manner consistent with the Privacy Act.
a. Interaction with the Detainee
Given the importance of considering information
from the detainee, the multidisciplinary team
shall make a good faith attempt to interview the
detainee and determine the nature of the
detainee's disability, any difficulties the detainee
experiences in accessing the facility or its
programs or services, and the detainee's specific
requests or needs for accommodation, if any.
The multidisciplinary team will respect any
detainee's decision to decline to participate in the
accommodation process, including the invitation
to interview with the multidisciplinary team. If a
detainee declines such an invitation, the
multidisciplinary team will document this
declination.
b. Multidisciplinary Team Determinations
The multidisciplinary team will determine
whether the detainee has a disability, whether the
detainee requires an accommodation to
meaningfully access the facility's programs and
activities, and whether to grant or recommend
denying the requested accommodation (if any) or
propose an alternate, equally effective
accommodation. The multidisciplinary team will
issue a, written decision, including the
documentation outlined below, within 5 working
days of the request or referral.
If there is a delay in determining whether to
approve an accommodation request or in
providing the detainee with an approved
accommodation, the multidisciplinary team shall
consider whether there are any interim
accommodations that would afford the detainee
access to its programs and activities pending the
final disposition of the request or the provision of
approved accommodations. The facility shall
provide to the detainee any such interim
accommodations it identifies.
Where the multidisciplinary team approves a
request for an accommodation; but the
recommended accommodation requires approval
from ICE (i.e., expenditures on medical
treatment, medication, and durable medical
equipment that require IHSC authorization), the
team will inform the detainee of the decision and
the status of the request with ICE and shall
consider whether to provide an interim
accommodation. The facility shall provide to the
detainee any such interim accommodations it
identifies,
Where the multidisciplinary team approves a
request for accommodations, and can
4.8 j Disability Identification, Assessment, and 350 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
immediately provide the necessary
accommodation, that decision will be the final
facility determination, and the team will follow
the notification procedures outlined below and
implement the approved accommodations as
quickly as possible.
c. Final Review of Any Denial by Facility
Administrator or Assistant Facility Administrator
Any denial by the multidisciplinary team of a
request for accommodation related to a disability
must be approved by the facility administrator or
assistant facility administrator. Such denials
include all cases in which the multidisciplinary
team determines that accommodations, including
all requested accommodations, should be denied;
or that alternate unrequested accommodation(s)
should be provided. The facility administrator
shall complete his or her review of the
multidisciplinary team's decision within 3
working days of the team decision.
d. Detainee Notification
The facility will provide the detainee with written
notification of the final decision on his or her
request for accommodation, regardless of
whether an accommodation was granted or
denied, and regardless of whether the
accommodation requires further approval by ICE.
Notification that an approved accommodation
request has been granted or submitted to ICE will
be provided at the conclusion of the
multidisciplinary team review. Notification of a
denied accommodation, or provision of an
alternate, unrequested accommodation, will be
provided only after review and concurrence by
the facility administrator or assistant facility
administrator, and will include a justification for
the denial. Notification shall be provided in a
language or manner the detainee can understand.
e. Staff Notification
Where an accommodation is granted, facility
policy or procedures will ensure that all relevant
facility staff, including facility security staff,
receive timely notification and, as needed,
instructions for successful implementation of the
accommodation. These procedures will also
account for any applicable privacy and
confidentiality considerations.
f. Initial and Periodic Reassessments
An initial re -assessment of approved
accommodations must be completed within 30
days of the original assessment by the
multidisciplinary team. All reassessments shall
include a good faith attempt to interview the
detainee regarding the current accommodations
provided and the need, if any, for changes to the
detainee's accommodation plan.
Subsequent periodic reassessments of approved
accommodations shall take place at a minimum
every 90 days thereafter, unless requested sooner
by the detainee. Such reassessments should
evaluate the efficacy of the accommodation (s)
provided, the continued need for accommodation
and whether alternate accominodation(s) would
be more effective or appropriate. Initial and
periodic reassessments shall be documented in
the detainee's medical and/or facility file.
g. Documentation
After the facility has completed its review of a
detainee with a disability or of a request for an
accommodation, facility staff shall place written
documentation of the following in the detainee's
medical and/or detention file, as appropriate:
1) date of the initial assessment interview with
the detainee with a potential disability, along
with the name(s) and title(s) of any/all facility
staff in attendance;
2) summary of the detainee's request, if any,
including any specific accommodations
requested, and any information or
.4.8 j Disability Identification, Assessment, and 351 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
observations related to the detainee's
disability;
3) finding on whether the detainee has a
disability and how the disability or
impairment limits the detainee's ability to
access programs or activities within the
detention setting;
4) the facility's final decision on any requested
accommodations;
5) provision of any aids or services to the
detainee, including the specific type(s) of
accommodation provided and/or steps taken
by the facility, and the implementation
date(s);
6) a copy of any written notification provided to
the detainee, including the justification in the
case of a denial; and
7) the results and date(s) of any reassessment(s),
if applicable, including reasons for any
decisions made.
G. Denial of an Accommodation
Permissible reasons for the facility to deny an
accommodation to a detainee who has been
determined to have a disability include: (1) the
detainee is not denied access to the facility's
programs or activities because of a disability; (2)
there is not a nexus between the disability and the
requested accommodation; (3) the requested
accommodation would fundamentally alter the
nature of the program, service, or activity; (4) the
requested accommodation would result in an undue
financial and administrative burden; or (5) the
detainee poses a direct threat to staff or other
detainees.
Both "fundamental alteration" and "undue financial
and administrative burden" are generally high
standards that are difficult to meet. Further, if a
particular accommodation would result in an undue
financial and administrative burden or fundamental
alteration, the facility must take any other action that
would not result in such an undue burden or
fundamental alteration but would nevertheless
ensure that, to the maximum extent possible,
detainees with a disability receive the benefits and
services of the program or activity. Similarly,
determinations that individuals pose a "direct threat"
are generally very rare, and require a careful,
individualized assessment as described below.
1. Fundamental Alteration
A "fundamental alteration" to a facility's programs,
services, or activities is a change that is so significant
that it alters the essential nature of the program,
service, or activity offered. Whether a change
constitutes a fundamental alteration is a
determination that must be made on a case-by-case
basis, and that must consider the unique
characteristics of each facility and each detainee with
a disability.
2. Undue Financial and Administrative Burden
An "undue financial and administrativeburden" is a
significant difficulty or expense related to a facility's
operations, programs, or activities. In evaluating
whether a particular accommodation would result in
an undue burden, the facility must consider all
resources available for use in the funding and
operation of the conducted program or activity as a
Whole.
3. Direct Threat
The facility may justify the denial of an
accommodation to a detainee with a disability on the
basis of the detainee posing a direct threat to staff or
other detainees only if providing the
accommodation would unavoidably exacerbate the
threat. The determination that a detainee with a
disability poses such a direct threat to staff or other
detainees must be reached through an individualized
assessment by a multidisciplinary team. The
assessment must rely on reasonable judgment and
current medical evidence, or the best available
4.8 l Disability Identification, Assessment, and 352 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
objective evidence, to determine the nature,
duration, and severity of the risk, and whether any
modifications of policies, practices, or procedures
can mitigate or eliminate the risk. Detainees who are
found to pose a direct threat are nevertheless entitled
to auxiliary aids or services to allow for effective
communication.
H. External Notifications
1. Notification of a Detainee with a
Communication or Mobility Impairment
The facility shall notify the Field Office Director as
soon as practicable, but no later than 72 hours, after
the multidisciplinary team has completed its review
of the needs of any detainee with a communication
or mobility impairment. This notification must
include, at a minimum,
a. the nature of the detainee's disability or
impairment;
b. the accommodation requested by the detainee;
and
c. the facility's plan to accommodate the detainee.
2. Notification of Facility Denials and Provision of
Alternative Accommodations
The facility shall notify the Field Office Director in
writing within 72 hours of any final denial by the
facility administrator or assistant facility
administrator of any accommodations request
reviewed by the multidisciplinary team. This
notification must include, at a minimum,
a. the nature of the detainee's disability;
b. the accommodation requested by the detainee;
c. the reason for denial; and
d. any steps the facility has taken to address the
detainee's needs.
ICE may review the facility's decrial of a request for
an accommodation. The facility shall provide
additional information as needed to further ICE's
review, and shall cooperate with ICE on any
additional steps that may be necessary.
1. Staff Training
Training on the facility's Disability and Reasonable
Accommodations procedures shall be provided to
employees, volunteers, and contract personnel, and
shall also be included in annual refresher training
thereafter, New facility staff, including contractors
and volunteers, shall receive this training as part of
the Initial Orientation training required by Standard
7.3. The level and type of training for volunteers
and contractors will be based on the services they
provide and their level of contact with detainees;
however, all volunteers and contractors who have
any contact with detainees must be notified of the
facility's disability accommodations policy.'
"Appendix 4.8.A: Resources" following this standard
lists resources available from the U.S. Department of
Justice and organizations that may be useful in
developing a training program, and/or for direct use
in training.
J. Detainee Orientation
The facility orientation program required by
standard 2. 1, "Admission and Release," and the
detainee handbook required by standard 6. 1,
"Detainee Handbook," shall notify and inform
detainees about the facility's disability
accommodations policy, including their right to
request reasonable accommodations and how to
make such a request. The facility will post other
documents for detainee awareness in detainee living
areas and in the medical unit, as requested by the
local ICE/ERO Field Office.
4.8 1 Disability Identification, Assessment, and 353 PBNDS 20il
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
Appendix 4.8.A: Resources
Note: This appendix is not, and should not be
interpretedas,legaladvice. Thisappendixis
intended only as a reference. The materials
referenced herein are non -exhaustive, and facilities
are responsible for determining whether and how
any additional laws apply.
Applicable Federal Laws and Regulations
Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as
amended, 29 U.S.C. § 794 (Section 504)
• Section 504 prohibits discrimination on the basis
of disability in programs conducted by Federal
agencies, in programs receiving Federal financial
assistance, in Federal employment, and in the
employment practices of Federal contractors.
Section 504 requires that no individual with a
disability may be denied the opportunity to
participate in a program, service, or activity
solely by reason of a disability. The facility is
required to provide reasonable modifications to
provide individuals with disabilities with an
equal opportunity to access, participate in, or
benefit from the facility's programs, services,
and activities. When considering what reasonable
modifications to provide, the facility will engage
in an interactive and individualized process that
considers the individual's needs and gives
primary consideration to the preferences of the
individual with a disability.
DHS' Section 504 implementing regulations:
C.F.R. Part 15
Link to DHS' Section 504 regulations:
htti2s•//www glo gov/fdsys/ag/CFR-2004-
title6-voll/ndf/CFR-2004-dtle6-voll-partly pdf
Architectural Barriers Act of 1968. 42 U.S.C. §§
4151 et seg. (ABA)
• The ABA requires that buildings and facilities
that are designed, constructed, or altered with
Federal funds, or leased by a Federal agency,
comply with Federal standards for physical
accessibility. ABA requirements are limited to
architectural standards in new and altered
buildings and in newly leased facilities. They do
not address die activities conducted in those
buildings and fatalities.
• Implementing Regulations: 41 CFR Subpart
101-19.6
• Link to the ABA: https://www access -
board. gov/ guidelines-and-standards/buildings-
and-sites /about-the-aba-standards
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
(DHS) Resources
Directive No, 065-01: Nondiscrimination for
Individuals with Disabilities in DHS -Conducted
Programs and Activities (Non -Em llooyment�
This Directive establishes the DHS policy and
implementation mechanisms for ensuring
nondiscrimination for individuals with
disabilities served by DHS -conducted programs
and activities under Section 504.
https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/Mes/public
ations / dhs-manag ement-directive-disability_
access 0 l.odf
Directive 065-01-001: Instruction on
Nondiscrimination for Individuals with a Disability
in DHS -Conducted Programs and Activities on-
EEWlo) trent)
• This Instruction implements the DHS Directive
065-01, Nondiscrimination for Individuals with
Disabilities in DHS -Conducted Programs and
Activities (Non -Employment).
httl2s://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/pLlbhc
ations/ dhs-instruction-nondiscrimination-
individuals-disabilities 03-07-15.pd
A Guide to Interacting with People who Have
Disabilities:
4.8 1 Disability Identification, Assessment, and 354 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
• The DHS Office for Civil Rights and Civil
Liberties developed this Guide to assist DHS
personnel, contractors, and grantees in their
interactions with people who have disabilities.
Under Section 504, DHS has a legal obligation. to
ensure nondiscrimination in the employment of
people with disabilities as well as by providing
program access, physical access, effective
communication, and reasonable accommodation
to people with disabilities encountered and
served by DHS programs and activities.
Examples of these interactions include detainees
with disabilities who are in ICE custody awaiting
a hearing or removal; this also includes
individuals with disabilities who are members of
the public, a family member, friend and/or
attorney of a detainee who seek to access ICE
programs, services and activities. Ensuring
nondiscrimination often begins by practicing
effective methods for interaction, such as treating
individuals with respect and using appropriate
language. This Guide offers a summary of
disability myths and facts, guidance on
appropriate language, and tips for successfully
interacting with people who have disabilities. It
is intended as a general overview of the topic
and does not supplant any specific policies and
procedures used by the DHS Components.
httl2s://www.dlis.gov/sites/default/files/12ublic
ations/ guide-interacting-with-peoole-who-have-
disabilties 09-26-13.ndf
Other Federal Government Resources
Disability.gov: www.dis_�bility.gov
Disability.gov is the U.S. federal government
website for comprehensive information about
disability -related programs, services, policies,
laws and regulations nationwide. The site links
to thousands of resources from many different
federal government agencies, as well as state and
local governments and nonprofit organizations
across the country. New resources are frequently
added to Disability.gov's 10 main subject areas:
Benefits, Civil Rights, Community Life,
Education, Emergency Preparedness,
Employment, Health, Housing, Technology and
Transportation.
U.S. Department of Tustice. Disability Rights Section:
www.ada.gov
•
ADA. gov is a website operated by the Disability
Rights Section in the Civil Rights Division of the
U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) to continuously
provide new and updated information and
guidance on the Americans with Disabilities Act
(ADA) and its requirements. DOJ also operates a
toll-free information line for those seeking to
comply with the ADA: (800) 514-0301 for
voice calls; or (800) 514-0383 for TTY. [Note:
The ADA does not apply to ICE's detention
programs and activities. However, ada.gov
provides helpful disability -related technical
assistance materials on various subjects.]
The U.S. Access Board: www.access-b6ard.gov
• .The U.S. Access Board is an independent federal
agency that promotes equality for people with
disabilities through leadership in accessible
design and the development of accessibility
guidelines and standards for the built
environment, transportation, communication,
medical diagnostic equipment, and information
technology. The Board develops and maintains
design criteria for the built environment, transit
vehicles, telecommunications equipment,
medical diagnostic equipment, and information
technology. The Board also provides technical
assistance and training on these requirements
and on accessible design and continues to
enforce accessibility standards that cover
federally funded facilities. The Board's Section
508 Standards apply to electronic and
information technology procured by the federal
government, including computer hardware and
software, websites, phone systems, and
4.8 1 Disability Identification, Assessment, and 355 PBNDS 2011
Accommodation (Revised December 2016)
copiers. They were issued under section 508 of
the Rehabilitation Act which requires access for
both members of the public and federal
employees to such technologies when
4.8 1 Disability Identification, Assessment, and
Accommodation
developed, procured, maintained, or used by
federal agencies. The Board operates a toll -free -
line: (800) 872-2253 or TTY (800) 993-2822.
356 PBNDS 2011
(Revised December 2016)