HRC FULL PACKET 2012-06-28 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

HEMA No. 2010-03 June 28, 2012 Page 4 It is asserted that the three proposed dormers on this elevatian wau[d also alter the character defining features of the structure (roof configuration) on primary elevations, thereby not in compliance with Standards 2, 3, 4, 5, and 9. The proposed dormers, although offering a practical benefit of providing more light and air into the attic of the building, are also a conjectural architectural feature that create a false sense of historical development and are not recommended. The wrap-around parch and dormers would also substantially alter the character defining features of the Colonial Revival facade, roof configuration, and the original Victorian fenestration pattern, and is considered a negative impact to the resource by providing a false sense of history, and do not meet Standards 2, 3, 4, 5, and 9. Proposed Changes to__the West Elevation The applicant wishes to have a balcony from an upstairs bedroom, as well as an additional entry/exit from the first floor to the front porch. The existing west elevation has a Victorian two-story vertical fagade, and a flat roof window bay with original roof cornice detail, wood siding and original tall rectangular Victorian windows with wood trim. The proposed new construction requires the removal of siding to install the porch roof structure that will extend aver the west elevation. It also necessitates removing the decorative bay roof cornice in order #o install a second floor bedroom balcony with railing. Access to the first floor porch and the balcony require the removal of original Victorian windows to install the new French doors. Additionally, three attic dormers with single hung windows are proposed for this hipped roof elevatian requiring the alteration of portions of the roof structure to construct the dormers. Although the proposed balcony, addition of dormers, and removal of two Victorian windows to install 1=rench doors would be attractive, they have the potential to substantially alter the character defin[ng features of the Colonial Revival facade and primary elevations, and may be considered a negative impact to the resource by providing a false sense of history, and does not meet Standards 2, 3, 4, 5, and 9. Unfortunately, the removal of the Victorian windows and the installation of French doors have already been completed without permit or approval (Exhibit 7) and are in violation of the SAMC. Should the Commission approve this alteration, permits may be retroactively obtained if they meet building code requirements. Should the Commission deny this alteration, the applicant would have to restore the Victorian windows. Conclusion Preservation of character defining features is vital to retaining the identity and integrity of a historic structure. Protecting the overall historic character defining features is the goal of historic designation. The significance of the McGowan farmhouse is based on both its Victorian and